Helping High School Students Recognize Their Progress
It can be difficult for students to see their own growth—unless you make it visible for them. Here are some ways to do that.
Your content has been saved!
Go to My Saved Content.Even after having spent weeks learning something, students sometimes tell me that they feel like they are not improving. They tell me they cannot remember the vocabulary, explain or apply what they have learned without looking at their notes, or get something they have designed to work.
I have noticed that they often overlook how their approach to these challenges has changed since they started.
As a Spanish and STEAM educator, I want students to recognize that their progress is not solely represented by a grade or a finished product. As students work through my classes, I try to highlight examples so they can recognize their growth: speaking with less hesitation than before, explaining why their approach failed, or identifying the next step to take on their own before asking for help. These are all signs of progress.
However, recognizing growth requires more than telling students they have improved. They need opportunities to consider the evidence of learning, identify what has changed, and connect that change to something they did. I tell them to look at the level of difficulty and their perception of how it has changed for them.
Identifying growth
In language learning, students tend to focus on what they are unable to say or write. Some students understand a conversation in the target language but still struggle to respond. They may communicate a complete thought while still making grammatical errors. If being correct is the only thing that students focus on, the important progress they make along the way might go unnoticed.
I’ve had students who initially respond to a question with a one-word answer but later reply with a full sentence and additional details. Their sentence may need to be corrected, but they are starting to communicate more. Acknowledging their progress helps build confidence while also helping to identify what they need to practice.
In my STEAM course, students might receive a coding error, but they learn how to find the problem, and their confidence builds each time they meet a challenge. I might tell a student, “You identified where the problem started and tested one change.” This can help them recognize their growth, and they’ll begin to see that they have strategies to use when they meet a challenge.
Revisiting earlier work
Another way to highlight growth is by having students revisit their earlier work. When they have something to compare their current work with—such as an early explanation or the first design of a project—it is easier for them to recognize progress.
In Spanish class, I have used Padlet and Book Creator with students as a way to introduce themselves or describe their interests. Another thing I’ve done is use podcast platforms and Flipgrid to have students respond to prompts. Later, I would have students respond to a similar prompt and then compare their recordings. A comparison like this should focus on the learning goal. Have they provided more detailed responses, made fewer grammatical errors, improved pronunciation, or communicated more clearly?
This can work across different content areas. Students might review an explanation of a science concept or the evidence supporting a written claim. You can ask them to consider what they can now do that was difficult for them before.
Reflecting on learning is an important part of the learning process, but it does not have to take a lot of time. Provide students with prompts, and set aside a few minutes in class to give them time to think through their progress. Here are some example prompts:
- Something I can do now that I could not do before is…
- The part of my work that shows this is…
- A strategy that helped me was…
- My next step is…
Sometimes, students may look at their work and still struggle to identify progress. We can review it with them, acknowledge what remains difficult, and identify a manageable next step. These conversations with students help us to understand whether a strategy is working or if they need a different approach or additional support.
It is also helpful if we model for students how to communicate their identified growth to their teachers. Students can respond orally, annotate prior work, or write a few sentences. The chosen format should make their thinking accessible and visible.
Documenting progress
A simple routine is to set aside a few minutes, maybe every other Friday, for students to add an artifact to a growth folder. The artifact could be digital or on paper. Students should include the date, identify the skill, and write a short explanation about why they chose it. Over the course of a few weeks, they will build a record that is useful during an individual conference or a conversation with families. The goal is to help each student recognize their individual growth over time, rather than comparing their growth with classmates.
For teachers, these conversations also provide valuable feedback about instruction. If students can identify what helped them learn, we gain insight into our teaching methods and the supports we are using, and can continue or adjust as needed. If students cannot identify their growth, we can determine if they need more specific criteria, different learning opportunities, or additional support.
It’s important to help students understand that they don’t have to master everything before they have something worth recognizing. Providing a clearer explanation, choosing a more effective strategy, or attempting a task with greater independence—these are all evidence of growth. When we help students notice those changes, they will be better prepared to take on the next challenge they encounter.
