Pack Your Bag
Students can list facts about a topic, but struggle to use them. This activity forces a choice: five items, one bag, and a justification for each that must cite evidence. It works as a preview before a unit, a check for understanding in the middle, or a review at the end.
Your content has been saved!
Go to My Saved Content.Downloads
How to use
Ideal for upper elementary and middle school reading and social studies classrooms, this two-page resource contains a one-page teacher guide with a three-step overview, side-by-side examples of weak and strong justifications, and a quick check for evaluating evidence. It also includes a student worksheet with space to justify five items and reflect on one item left behind. Print one worksheet per student (or one per pair), and share the sample justifications aloud before students start packing.
This activity asks students to choose five items to bring to a specific time, place, person, or moment in a text, then justify each choice with evidence. The more specific the destination, the stronger the work, so push students toward a precise moment rather than a broad topic. Use it as a preview before a unit, a mid-unit check for understanding, or a review at the end.
The justification is where the real thinking happens. A justification only counts if it cites evidence and explains why that evidence matters, not just why the item seems useful. After students pack their bags, have them compare choices in small groups, question each other's evidence, and vote as a class on the single most important item. For younger students, scale it down to three items with a drawing and a spoken fact; for older students, require a page number or source and add a weight or cost limit so they have to rank what matters most.
Educator Tips:
Model a Weak and a Strong Answer: Share the "not enough" and "justified with evidence" examples with students before they start, so they can hear the difference between an assertion and a claim backed by evidence.
Use the Three-Part Check: When students share their justifications, have listeners check for all three things: evidence cited, evidence explained, and reasoning that a student who skipped the text couldn't fake.
Don't Skip Left Behind: The items students cut are often as revealing as the ones they keep. Make time for students to explain what evidence changed their minds, since that's where you'll see them weighing evidence against each other rather than just listing it.
Run It Twice for Growth: For a longer unit, have students pack the bag before and after instruction, then compare the two. It gives you a quick, visible measure of what they learned.
