George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

Maximizing Profit: The PBL Classroom Without PBL

Danielle Lynch

Math Teacher from Bellevue WA
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Share

Facilitating problem-based learning (PBL) in the classroom requires a shift in pedagogy from a "stand and deliver" class. The problem presented at the beginning of a PBL cycle must create an authentic need for students to develop 21st century skills such as:

  • Collaboration
  • Communication
  • Problem solving
  • Reflection skills

A problem we presented in our math classroom is: "How can the student store maximize profit?" This question serves as a strong avenue to facilitate collaboration, meaning that when students try to work alone, it is too hard or too large of a task. PBL requires students to communicate their understanding of the problem, helping them develop critical thinking skills and increasing academic discourse in the classroom. Reflection is also an important part of a PBL cycle. Students should reflect on their process of solving the problem, but also on how collaboration, strong communication skills and thinking critically with peers made the process more manageable. Once students see value in these skills, they can begin making them part of everyday work, whether or not a PBL-focused problem is present.

Take caution, however. These skills are not simply present just because of a PBL cycle -- they must be taught.

Student Collaboration

Once students see a need for collaboration, it becomes the teacher's role to set the foundation. Establishing group norms can be an opportunity for students to become familiar with their peers as learners. As we consider our math problem about maximizing profit, students will have to discuss important vocabulary such as profit and income. Collaboration also provides a space for students to talk about how they will hold each other accountable. Another important aspect is helping them be aware of equity in their group, how are they communicating with others, helping group members to understand their point of view and vice versa. As they think about maximizing profit, students will have to make sure they have a common understanding of the zeros in the parabola representing the "break-even points." After establishing expectations, the teacher must work to maintain high collaboration standards through giving feedback and helping student groups sort out conflict. This can include checking for understanding or facilitating discussions about why everyone in the group hasn't built a common understanding.


Productive group work involves communicating with team members, a 21st century skill. Communication is also very important when thinking about how the work will be completed, because the workload could become unevenly distributed if group members do not communicate often. Modeling how to ask questions to clarify statements, gain others' perspectives and check for understanding is an important part keeping communication open.

Problem-Solving Skills

Modeling how to solve a problem can be a very powerful way for students to make inferences about what skills are needed. During a problem cycle, teachers can ask questions to help students develop and use their problem-solving skills. For example, teachers could have groups formulate a plan for solving the problem, then ask clarifying questions about both the problem and their process as students work to solve the problem. When thinking about maximizing profit, students will have to work with their group and apply the mathematical definition of a vertex in the context of the problem. This will require students to build understanding about the x-axis representing the number of price changes based on their price interval. It can also build confidence for students to talk about their errors or misconceptions and the process their group used to correct the error. An error may include thinking that the axis of symmetry represents the price change or the price to produce the maximum profit. Ultimately, teachers need to help students recognize the skills they are building throughout the process by being transparent.

Valued Skills Remain in Use

In the video Problems of Practice, I address that, in our Algebra 2 PBL Curriculum Writing Team, we found units where an authentic PBL problem would restructure the unit so that students deepen their understanding of math through a real-life application. For those units where we didn't see a strong fit, we left them as a more traditional curriculum. This is where the shift in pedagogy happens. Just because students are not involved in a PBL unit, such as maximizing profit, doesn't mean that they can't use the skills they have gained through working with their peers.

After establishing a classroom where collaboration, communication and critical thinking skills are valued and used by students, the atmosphere of that classroom changes. I saw this in my own classroom through students asking each other questions and working together without having to be prompted. The skills established though PBL units are more evident. Students are more confident about explaining how they solved a problem, or where their point of confusion lies within solving a problem. The teacher can take on the role of thinking about creating opportunities for students to use their skills through the traditional unit.

Overall, the skills established through PBL units have enriched the classroom, creating more of a team approach to learning, versus a classroom where the teacher is the only source of new information.

Was this useful?
A Project-Based Case Study: Sammamish High School

Comments (4) Sign in or register to comment Follow Subscribe to comments via RSS

Robin Ruiz- Teacherparent's picture
Robin Ruiz- Teacherparent
Candidate for a PhD in Education Learning Instruction Innovation Lifelong Learner

We have a virus in our school ! An infectious disease - testing is over - I love the fact I can visualize your setting ! I can live it and breath it and feel inspired because of the Learning ! What percentage of students are not engaged ? What do you do with the 6 or 7 students who come to school daily to disrupt classes! I will admit -classroom management , consistency , and teacher collaboration are not at forefront.
Does PBL start with staff ? Is it a possibility that leadership gets it's math department together to focus not only on benchmark assessments and teaching basic skills but asking each other in small groups , How can we engage all students?
Who does this ? And what makes this work in your classes? So what does your school do to create Authentic Learning? 60% of our school was not at grade level in reading these students are detatched from learning! I believe they all can do so much better! And so can we !

Samer Rabadi's picture
Samer Rabadi
Online Community Engagement Manager

Wow, Robin, that's a lot of questions. :-)

The amount of information out there about PBL is wide and deep. A good place to start learning more is right here on Edutopia. Check out the following page for some resources:

You might also want to look at the Buck Institute for Education (BIE). They have a ton of PBL resources as well:

Laura Thomas's picture
Laura Thomas
Director, Antioch University New England Center for School Renewal, Author of Facilitating Authentic Learning, Director of the Antioch Critical Skills Program; Elementary Library Media Specialist

Hi Robin-
Love your enthusiasm. As Samer said, that's a lot of questions- but you're asking the right ones! The answer to many of them is "Yes!" Yes it begins with staff. Yes it's possible even with all the competing demands. Yes, we can all do better!

At Antioch (where I teach) we talk about the shift from the traditional classroom model to PBL as akin to the journey from one side of a river to the other. In many cases, the river is too wide to make the trip in one jump, so it's imperative that we provide lily pads that teachers and students can use to make th trip. (Not stepping stones because those are too stable- lily pads require you to keep moving!)

We find those lily pads via the Critical Skills Classroom ( Give me a holler at acer(at)antioch (dot) edu if you want to talk more!

Cindy Laurin's picture
Cindy Laurin
Home schooling three children in Ben Lomond Ca.

Actually this type of classroom has been around for a long time, Montessori and other alternative education.. It is human nature to problem solve, let it happen!! For years you've put kids in desks and made them dependent on the teacher for their education. Watch how they can work together, at their own pace, come up with their own ideas!! all with little help from a teacher. WOW! then they are really in charge of their own education... they can know that they are capable of steering their education and an official teacher is NOT the only way to get it... These ideas are not new at all!! Hope the universities that credential teachers has the insight to require their students to see alternative ways of holding a classroom, of looking at students as capable. Become an observer of your students, like say hardly anything in class, sit amongst them not above them, be an eager kid wanting to learn too, they'll follow. Remember there is no timeline for kids to learn, they all learn at a different pace!!!!! Don't be the assembly line classroom. LOOK at how alternative teachers/classrooms work,, so important!!! Most have never seen a Montessori elementary classroom... As I was getting my Montessori teaching certificate it was required of me, and all in the program, to go out and observe many, many types of classrooms. ALL STUDENTS WILL NOT BE ENGAGED IN THE SAME THING AT THE SAME TIME!! CHILDREN ARE NOT ROBOTS....please remember this. Authentic meaningful work is different to each child. What is authentic and meaningful to teachers is not necessarily the same for the children. It is that simple. Broaden your horizons and go observe other types of classrooms/ philosophies!!!

Sign in to comment. Not a member? Register.