Collage illustration of students in a glowing grid field, staring at a classroom whiteboard with the cut-out of a teacher in the center.
Collage by Annelise Capossela for Edutopia, iStock (5)
AI in Education

With AI Lessons, Students Sense Your Absence

Students find AI-generated lessons less engaging and less important than ones planned by their teachers, new research shows.

November 19, 2026

Your content has been saved!

Go to My Saved Content.

Jack Mulvaney remembers how his ninth-grade math teacher, Ms. Pemberton, would enthusiastically dole out points for each correct answer. Mulvaney had no interest in math, but Ms. Pemberton’s excitement was infectious enough to get him invested. He recalls Mr. Cook, his middle school social studies teacher, who played the trivia game Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon with his students. The game didn’t have a pedagogical purpose, “but it was so much fun,” Mulvaney recalls. “I felt like the time he spent building relationships with us helped me buy into learning.” And, nearly 25 years later, he has fond memories of his middle school resource room teacher, Ms. Starksy, who always listened whenever he got in trouble—and he got in trouble a lot.

Those teachers had an indelible effect on Mulvaney because of the effort they made to connect with him and other students. Now 36, Mulvaney strives to treat his students at Sanford Middle School in Minneapolis with the same degree of attention. As his memories show, students notice those efforts. And they can tell that behind each of his lessons is a human being who cares deeply about something that may be difficult to understand.

Students can also tell, it turns out, when that human touch is absent. A new study out of the University of Pennsylvania, “Generative AI Can Harm Teaching,” suggests that when teachers use AI to plan their lessons, students feel less engaged and less confident in the material, and less likely to think the lessons are important. Students don’t even have to know the lessons were generated by AI, the study reports: They intuit the difference between them and those planned by a human—and respond accordingly.

Great Potential, Serious Drawbacks

The research team, led by Angela Duckworth, randomly divided more than 500 teachers, collectively teaching about 14,000 students across 24 K–12 schools in Turkey, into three groups: a business-as-usual control, another that received a custom-built generative AI teaching support tool, and a third with access to the same tool plus weekly reminders to use it along with feedback on student usage.

Teachers who used the tool tended to engage with it just enough to generate a lesson, rather than developing the lesson through a series of back-and-forths, and the more control teachers relinquished to the tool, the less interested their students were in the lesson. Students’ “intrinsic motivation scales with the intensity of their teachers’ AI use,” the authors write. “The more instruction is mediated through AI, the more the relational and affective components of teaching might be displaced.”

The more teachers used the AI tool, the more they, too, began to recognize its limits. Teachers who initially relied heavily on AI “grew more pessimistic,” the authors write—possibly because “acquaintance with AI and its dazzling output initially leads teachers to think it improves their performance but, with experience, they come to realize its drawbacks.”

HOW AI CAN BE USEFUL

None of this is to say AI can’t be useful to teachers. A 2026 UK study, “Embedding AI in Education,” found that AI tools can significantly reduce planning time, enhance teacher confidence, and support inclusive practices. But it must be “integrated critically and collaboratively,” the study cautions, and not replace professional judgment.

Here are three ways AI can be helpful, without sapping the human qualities that define effective teaching.

Time Saver: A 2026 Gallup-Walton Family Foundation survey found that about 60 percent of K–12 teachers use AI in their work. AI tools can help teachers draft letters to parents, write rubrics, organize their gradebook, and handle other administrative tasks, freeing up time for planning lessons, giving thoughtful feedback, and meeting with students.

Thought Partner: AI tools can help with brainstorming, research, and reverse-engineering lessons from desired goals. Veteran teacher Mary Beth Hertz likes to give her learning outcomes to Claude with guidance on exactly what she wants students to gain along the way. Then she iterates on lessons through a series of prompts to ensure the lessons accomplish what she wants them to.

But Hertz warns that because LLMs work by scouring the internet, a teacher should never entirely offload their creative work to a bot. “The internet is full of problematic pedagogy, and replacing your years of experience or content knowledge with the text that an LLM spits out is similarly problematic,” she writes. Instead, she advises teachers to see AI as a collaborator that can help them expand their teaching repertoire.

Differentiation Aid: AI tools can help teachers customize learning materials for individual students faster than they could on their own. In the Gallup-Walton survey, 64 percent of the teachers said AI tools improve the quality of materials adapted to a broad spectrum of student needs. But again, intentionality is essential. Would-be improvements can be quickly negated if the materials are generic, biased, or unreliable. As Hertz notes, teachers should treat AI as a thought partner, and not as a substitute for their expertise.

TRAINING IS ESSENTIAL

While AI tools can be powerful assistants, true educational innovation relies on relationships, dialogue, and shared inquiry. The authors of the UK study write that “professional communities and collaborative practices are central to responsible AI adoption.”

As schools and districts worldwide establish AI policies, those in the classroom will need to learn how to use these tools to best augment their teaching. Stephanie Marken, senior partner for U.S. research at Gallup, says that while AI can save teachers valuable time and strengthen the quality of their work, proper training and support should be school leaders’ top priority. “Schools need to provide the tools, training, and support to make effective AI use possible for every teacher,” she said.

And effective teaching, Jack Mulvaney says, is all about connection, rather than the mere transfer of information. He quotes a favorite line from Maya Angelou: “I’ve learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did. But people will never forget how you made them feel.”

Share This Story

  • bluesky icon
  • email icon

Filed Under

  • AI in Education
  • Curriculum Planning
  • Education Trends

Follow Edutopia

  • facebook icon
  • bluesky icon
  • pinterest icon
  • instagram icon
  • youtube icon
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
George Lucas Educational Foundation
Edutopia is an initiative of the George Lucas Educational Foundation.
Edutopia®, the EDU Logo®, Teacher 2 Teacher Logo®, and Lucas Education Research Logo® are trademarks or registered trademarks of the George Lucas Educational Foundation in the U.S. and other countries.