George Lucas Educational Foundation

Schools That Work | Practice

School 21

Grades pre-K to 13 | London, U.K.

Arts-Infused Project-Based Learning: Crafting Beautiful Work

Learn how to bring cross-curricular, arts-infused project-based learning into your classroom.
PrintPrint
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Share
Transcript

Ahmet: Project-based learning at School 21 is put right at the heart of education.

Student: Here, put that one there on the wall.

Ahmet: Art brings knowledge, stories, facts alive, so you get engagement from students. You get students caring what they're learning about.

Student: Much better! Let's do it one more time!

Peter: I think one of the big messages of this school is to do things in greater depth. We are passionate here about crafting work until it is beautiful. And my rule of thumb for the products that we create here is, "Are you surprised that a student that age has done that?"

Teacher: So did you make it?

Peter: I think project-based learning is a very powerful way of getting quality work, and it makes a real impact on learning.

Oli: The model that we've come to in project-based learning is we've linked together what you might call knowledge rich subjects, history and science, with performative subjects, music, drama.

Joe: Our cross-curricular projects I usually want long. And so between 12/15 weeks. And they will have 300 minutes per week in-between the two subjects.

Joe: Your assignment is to create a three- to five-minute immersive theater performance, which is based around the French or Russian Revolution. So you are responsible in your groups for writing the script, for making the set, for directing your own performance.

Matilda: So I think the priority is we just need to run through it.

Student: We need to also get props and everything set.

Joe: Project-based learning, to me, is a backwards planning structure. You sort of go, "Right, what's going to drive this whole project? And what are we going to produce at the end? And who's it going to be for?" Then once you have that, we then say to them, "Here are all the mini-deadlines on the way." They work in teams. They work individually. They have problems to solve. They have information to gather.

Matilda: I really like how we get a lot of independence in our projects. Our play is about the soldiers, how poor the conditions were for them, and so how appealing the prospect of communism was.

Student: [yelling] Get in, and fall in the right hand side! Right now!

Zaid: To fit all those key events that happened in history in a five-minute play is quite difficult.

Student: [yelling at masked soldiers]

Zaid: We were new to the fact that it was immersive theater, and the fact that the audience could not speak, but to feel that they were part of this.

Student: We're approaching Russia where everybody will be free!

Matilda: One of the things this school values a lot is craftsmanship. So we keep on redrafting everything that we do. We've been receiving critique to help improve that.

Student: It's kind of rushed. So I think they should slow it down, or space it out a little.

Ahmet: It points them to the direction of what needs to be improved, what's not quite clear, where they need to add more knowledge.

Ahmet: Great guys, really nice comments. I would like you got go and get--

Emily: I'd argue that the arts is project-based learning. Students are constantly working towards an end product that will have authentic audience.

Emily: We are a week away from Exhibition. So what we're going to do today is make sure that all the aspects of this project is completely prepared, edited, critiqued, and ready to go.

Emily: It's the first time we've brought music and science together. The essential question of the project is "What does sound look like?"

Heather: We've mapped out the science that we could include in that. So students have learnt about sound, soundwaves, how it's made.

Emily: Over the course of the project there, we team teach all 40 students together; and there'll be other times we divide them in half.

Heather: And I can't say the kids would have learnt the science as well as they would have done if it weren't for the music. It's so much more real, and it becomes a lot less theoretical.

Heather: Which of these bars are used to describe the waves getting bigger?

Aman: I think it's quite fascinating how science can actually be used to make music. I admit, I would get bored of just reading a book about science. We learnt how you can be active and learn at the same time.

Emily: We wanted to find a way of making a physical performance. So we constructed the Boomwhackers.

Heather: So they were looking at measuring different lengths of tubes to find out how that affected pitch.

Emily: And they were color-coded, red is C, orange is D, yellow E, etcetera. They can then see the visual representation of how frequency works by the number of hertz when they hit that Boomwhacker.

Student: One, two, three, four, boom!

Emily: Just to make it a little bit more exciting, we discovered these amazing Makey Makey devices, provided students are holding the conducting part of the circuit, you can play notes through it. [notes being played] It also works through water, which we've color-coded.

Aman: So when you touch the water, a sound comes out from the laptop. [music notes play by touching the water] We've been practicing for a really long time. And I want to see how it turns out.

Matilda: We have Exhibition Night at the end of every term. It's a night where all the projects we've been doing have come together and we show them to our parents, to visitors, experts in the areas we're studying.

Student: [yelling] What are you doing? Why are you killing these innocent people? They don't deserve to die!

Matilda: Having a real audience is really important. It definitely helps you keep motivated when you know you're doing it for a reason.

Aman: After all of that hard work in the term, you get to like show it to the community, and be proud of your work. [whistle blows; music]

Emily: Bringing the arts into project-based learning is great, because students can express the content in a creative and physical way.

Peter: I think the students, once you've crafted something beautiful for the first time, then you never look back. They're getting a sense of what excellence looks like. They're getting all those qualities of resilience and perseverance of thinking, "Well, actually, I really have gone on a journey." [music; applause; cheering; crowd noise]

Get Video
Embed Code Embed Help

You are welcome to embed this video, download it for personal use, or use it in a presentation for a conference, class, workshop, or free online course, so long as a prominent credit or link back to Edutopia is included. If you'd like more detailed information about Edutopia's allowed usages, please see the Licenses section of our Terms of Use.

Credits
  • Video Producer: Sarita Khurana
  • Editor: Melissa Thompson
  • Director of Photography: Dominic Sant
  • Second Camera: Chris Guiver
  • Sound: James Shearing
  • Production Assistant: Liam Gadd
  • Production Coordinator: Julia Lee
  • Post-Production Supervisor: Anna Fields
  • Motion Graphic Design & Color: Douglas Keely
  • Assistant Edit: Christian Amundson
  • Head of Production: Gillian Grisman
  • Director of Video: Amy Erin Borovoy
  •  
  • Production Crew:
  • Evans Woolfe Media

Overview

School 21 infuses the arts into a project-based learning model, emphasizing personalized learning and redrafting multiple revisions in the process of iteration. This London-based public school teaches students from Reception through Year 11 (approximately pre-K to 11th grade), and will ultimately serve through Year 13.

At the secondary level (Years 7 through 11), each PBL unit is co-taught by a core academic subject teacher and an arts teacher. School 21 believes that integrating the arts and PBL is a natural fit.

"I would argue that the arts is project-based learning," says Emily Crowhurst, a music teacher. "In every music lesson, whether it's a project lesson or what you might deem a typical lesson, there are project-based learning techniques going on naturally in the way that students are constantly critiquing and rehearsing what they're creating; and they're always working towards an end project that will have an authentic audience."

"My PBL process is one that mirrors the art form," adds Ahmet Ahmet, a drama teacher. "For me, project-based learning is putting on a performance."

Every student takes one co-curricular, arts-infused PBL course per 12- to 15-week term. "When we were doing immersive theatre," recalls Matilda, a Year 9 student, "it gave me a chance to put myself in the shoes of the people at the time and to experience history through their eyes. The history livens up the drama, and the drama livens up the history."

Related Article: How to Infuse the Arts Into Core Curriculum (and Why It Matters)

How It's Done

When Planning Your Project, Ask for Feedback

At School 21, teachers plan their project in the term prior to teaching it. For feedback, they put their proposal through the tuning protocol -- a group critique among staff -- multiple times. "The first tuning is an ideas tuning -- from an early, nascent form, getting feedback on initial ideas and overall design," says Jess Hughes, an English teacher. "Later tunings are on the detailed plan and are used to interrogate practicalities, iron out concerns, and ensure academic rigour."

In the planning stages, her Romeo and Juliet project went through three tunings, taking a total of 80 minutes. In her post "Tuning Protocol: A Framework for Personalized Professional Development," she explains how to set up your tuning protocol norms and the six steps of the protocol itself. You can also follow School 21's Project Planning Structure guide (PDF) to plan your project from the first to last tuning.

Use a PBL Project Planning Checklist

Joe Pardoe, a history teacher, and Ahmet, a drama teacher, were paired to create an arts-infused PBL project. Together, they planned how they could teach about both immersive theater and the French and Russian Revolutions. Below is School 21's PBL project planning checklist detailing these teachers' plans.

1. Essential Question: What question or problem will drive the project? How do we use immersive theater -- where the audience becomes part of the play -- to tell a story within the French or Russian Revolution?

2. Authentic Audience and Exhibition of Beautiful Work: What is the vision? Who is it for? Why are they learning it? Students will perform their play to a public audience, including the local history association, immersive theater actors and producers, and 200 other community members.

3. End product: What is being created? The end products will be a three- to five-minute immersive theater performance and an essay.

4. Significant content: Is curriculum content properly covered? Students will focus on weaknesses within the leadership, emerging ideas during that time, and an issue -- economic, political, or social -- that led to the revolution. They'll also have to incorporate specific drama techniques, and focus on a particular event, like the storming of the Bastille.

5. Rigorous assessment (including the opportunities for 1:1s with all students): How will you ensure the children have learned and made progress? Students will be assessed with non-graded multiple choice tests at the beginning of most lessons, one-on-one and small group conversations each lesson, weekly essay workshops and play critiques by their peers, and their final performance. Students will also be assessed by theater professionals and a historian who will watch their play and spend about 15 to 20 minutes with them in a question-and-answer session.

6. Timelines and transparency: Has the flow of the project been considered? How will you share this with students? The immersive play and essay will be broken down into smaller deliverables with weekly critiques and deadlines. On day one, students will get a design brief outlining their final product, their authentic audience, the content they need to cover, and their deadlines throughout the process.

7. Student choice: What aspects of the project will allow students to express themselves creatively? Students will choose which revolution they will focus on -- either the French or Russian Revolution. They'll also choose who they'll group with for their play, how their play unfolds (and what they need to learn to create an accurate and strong script and performance), and the focus of their essay -- as long as it's related to either revolution.

8. Grounding text: What will students read in order to develop their understanding? Over the holidays, students will watch a documentary, read at least part of a textbook, and read a scene from a play. They'll have their textbook to work with throughout the course of the term, and they'll also watch speeches, documentaries, and listen to immersive theater experts speak in class.

Give Your Students a Design Brief

Students meet three times a week for 100-minute class periods. On day one, both teachers launch the project with a design brief -- outlining what the final product will be, what they need to include in it, all of the deadlines from start to finish, and who their audience will be at exhibit night.

"From day one, we say, 'This is your end product. It is going to happen -- the exhibition -- on this date and time.' We give our students the complete brief so they know from day one what they should be doing," explains Pardoe. This allows students to take ownership and direction over their own learning, and plan how to meet deadlines at their own pace.

Choose Your Teaching Style

How the content and class are taught varies with the teaching style of those collaborating. Some teachers choose to co-teach every class, while others split the students in two groups, teach the subjects separately, and bring everyone back together for key co-taught classes. In either case, teachers integrate elements of their own discipline with their co-teacher's, with their students' end products ultimately reflecting both content areas.

Crowhurst and Heather Birtwistle (music and science) split their class into two and rotate them. During one week, students will go twice to music and once to science. The following week, they'll have two science classes and one music class. Throughout the term, they also have periods where all students come together to receive the design brief, for whole-class critiques or rehearsals, and during flexible sessions where students work on their products and ask for specific support. This combined class is creating multiple end products: dance music tracks, a Cymatics music video (showing the physicality of sound), and short videos explaining the learning behind their products.

"We've got certain lessons that are fixed," says Birtwistle. "In science, they absolutely need to know the laws of reflection. So we'd go to the science lab and we would have a standard science lesson, and next time, we'd have a standard lesson about refraction, but then the next lesson would be a more flexible period spending time creating their dance track, editing their music video, or filming themselves explaining their learning."

Meanwhile, Pardoe and Ahmet co-teach each history and drama class. "For me, a true fusion is two practitioners with a large group, doing it together. That's my style," says Ahmet. "Students might write an essay for 20 minutes, have a critique session, write some of their script, and then the last ten minutes they'll do a run-through. It's one big project, rather than separate lessons."

Foster Student-Directed Learning

When making their product, students learn to see their own gaps in knowledge and are able to go to either teacher, letting them know what learning they need to improve their product throughout the term.

Instead of whole-class lessons, Pardoe is able to personalize his students' learning by their interests and needs. When students come to him asking to learn more about a topic, he'll pull about 12 students together and facilitate Harkness debates -- student-led discussions at an oval table where everyone can see each other and participate. He'll give them something to read beforehand so that they'll come to the debate prepared to speak.

"Students have a chance to spend 20 minutes discussing a problem or discussing some content in depth," says Pardoe. "At the end of the session, I feedback how they performed and also clarify any misconceptions that I heard. It's a way of developing knowledge in students, but it also allows them to talk about and think through their ideas."

Assess Your Students While They're Making Their Product

Birtwistle and Crowhurst use the flexible time while students are working on their products to assess and deepen student learning. "For the music and science link," says Birtwistle, "we've been looking at how you can show vibrations and how different styles of different frequencies and amplitudes might affect those vibrations."

While their students work on their dance tracks or edit their Cymatics video, Birtwistle and Crowhurst will observe them and ask questions to assess their understanding, such as:

  • Explain why this happens.
  • Explain why you've done this.
  • What is this showing about the science?
  • Tell me what would happen if you had done X rather than Z.

"By doing that, you can start analyzing how much have the students understood," says Birtwistle. "You can say, 'I know I need to speak to this student. I need to work with them because they still haven't understood what the difference between amplitude and frequency is.'"

Provide Targeted Support

If there's a gap in a student's knowledge, Pardoe will pull students into smaller groups -- even in groups of two -- and teach them content in a more traditional way.

"What’s brilliant about this process, and working with two teachers," explains Birtwistle, "is that you can start to target individual students who you know aren’t quite there yet. It provides the opportunity for students to work independently, but also provides pivot points in which you can start doing interventions with students quite intensely and within a lesson."

Foster a Culture of Redrafting

"One of the big messages of this school is to do things in greater depth," says Peter Hyman, a co-founder and executive head teacher at School 21. They achieve this through their redrafting process. "What I want to see is not just how good the third draft is, but what is the journey that you've gone on?" adds Hyman.

"It's the drafting and critiquing process that really drives the project," explains Pardoe. In his project with Ahmet, their students will bring in a plan for their essay and get it critiqued, then an introduction which is also critiqued, then a whole first draft focused on grammar, spelling, and punctuation -- and they'll continue to bring in drafts for critiques diving deeper into the concepts behind the essay. They show off their final essay on exhibit night -- either displayed in a book or on a wall.

Their students go through the same critique and redrafting process with working on their immersive play. "They make, they redraft, and they are critiqued," says Ahmet. "We do something called an audience response -- a peer critique. I don't want a top-down structure. I want them to make it for themselves. I want them to own what they do."

Seven teenage boys are standing together at the bottom of a school stairway, looking up, wearing white masks covering their eyes. A girl without a mask is standing across from them, looking toward them.
School 21 students are rehearsing their immersive play.

Students participate in a weekly audience response, giving feedback about what their peers might keep, add to, or take away from their play. "It points them to the direction of what needs to be improved, what's not clear, and where they need to add more knowledge," says Ahmet. "Our students are buying into this idea of a process. It's OK to not know enough. It's OK to have an idea and then find that actually that idea is completely irrelevant by week 10. What the play looks like in week one will have no resemblance by week 12."

You can adapt Ahmet's eight-step audience response protocol and read about his three tips for implementing it in his post, "The Power of Critique and Redrafting."

When a student spends a term redrafting one essay -- or a three- to five-minute play -- it allows him or her to cover a topic in depth. This process also creates a constant discussion among School 21 teachers: How can we teach a topic in depth, while still covering all the content on the exams?

Their solution: going deep into topics that bridge into other topics. "By spending more time on a gateway topic, we've gained a greater understanding that can be used for the other topics that we can cover in less depth," says Hyman. "We're finding our way towards the right mix. We haven't got all the answers yet, but that is the discussion that's going on here."

Redrafting also makes students aware of how far they've come in their learning. "When they’re getting that feedback, acting on that feedback, and changing things," says Birtwistle, "they can actually see that they can do something that’s really worthwhile and beautiful for them."

"Once you’ve crafted something beautiful for the first time," adds Hyman, "you never look back because you know the heights you can now reach."

Comments (7) Sign in or register to comment Follow Subscribe to comments via RSS

Ray_D's picture
Ray_D
Innovator, Entrepreneur, Instigator

Incredibly interesting integration of the arts into PBL. We hear so much about STEM and related disciplines taking advantage of PBL but we need to work harder to be more inclusive of all students. This applies not only to PBL but to innovation learning opportunities as well. It is the diversity of thought and background that results in the truly creative and outstanding outcomes and we have the potential to expand minds as to the art of the possible.

Ms. T's picture

I love how this school integrates there learning through using programs to create assignments based on art. How the students then came up with their own re-enactments for what they were portraying.
I am not familiar with Pre-k through 13. How does that translate to schools in the United States?

Emelina Minero's picture
Emelina Minero
Assistant Editor

Students enter School 21 at 4 years old. I think that's the age where they enter pre-K. Grade 7 -- at 11 years old -- is the start of their secondary education. They usually graduate from secondary at about 16 years old. It's starting to become more common in the U.K. to add grades 13 and 14, and students continue until they're 18.

(1)
Chris Doeller's picture
Chris Doeller
Pro vo-tech

This is a great idea, bit more often than not it makes the "arts" the hand maiden" for the academic subjects. If there is a solid arts curriculum, that all students of a school are receiving, then the arts integration into other areas has value. If this is the primary function of the arts program, or there is no ongoing arts program, then integration will be more of a prop than substantive. Its no difference than one school which has a school chorus, and they put on a holiday concert, vs the school which has no music program, and for a few weeks drills them on a few holiday songs. The latter results in little more than eye wash and a novelty.

Michael's picture

Schools in the United States can definitely benifit from integrating art assessment into curricula. Especially through project based learning with an emphasis on group collaboration, students can learn to actually use the knowledge gained throughout a particular unit and translate it into something deeper. Likewise, arts integration also poses a great opportunity for communities to view students work and hopefully recognize how hard students are working thought the year.

Tania Medina Marsilla's picture

Hello, I am a Spanish student in first year of Primary Education studies (from 6-12 yrs.old). First of all, thanks for your beautiful contribution to the children of this world. Your projects and methodology are very inspiring. I am making a blog for my ICT class and I am writing an article about you school, therefore, I would like to make you a few questions:

- How are ICT (communication and information technologies) introduced in the classrooms?
- Do you allow students to bring their own laptops at school or do you use the school computers?
- Do you allow any other device: mobile phone, tablet, etc?
- When are they used, at which state of the project, mostly making the final presentation to show of the results of the project? Or just at home when making research?
- What role do you give to ICT in the learning process, do you use learning objets such as web quests, do you reinforce the students learning with technological tools: games, apps, etc?
- How do you consider that ICT affects in social and emotional learning?

Thank you very much for your answers
Kind regards. Tania Medina

Sign in to comment. Not a member? Register.