George Lucas Educational Foundation

Powerful Little Bubbles

August 14, 2014
The latest round of district testing is finally over after spending two hours each morning for the past five days in complete silence surrounded by bubbles and number two pencils.  Ten hours.  Over.  At least until April when the State assessment arrives in sealed cartons under heightened security.

            Back to our regularly scheduled program...

            It is now time to dissect the data, label the kids, organize them into new groups and provide a new round of interventions to meet their individual needs.  Modern technology has provided my team with near-instant information.  With trepidation each day, we accessed our data and, like little kids, raced to each other's room asking, "Wad-ja-get?"  Yes, we know that we all had a part in each other's students' progress, and we accept and celebrate that group effort.  However, we also know that our individual professional reputation is firmly attached to the new ratings and that our individual credibility as teachers will, itself, be dissected, analyzed and evaluated.  Appropriate interventions will be created for us as well.

            All of this from ten hours of testing.  Quiet, yet very powerful little bubbles.

            I truly understand the value of student assessment, and I do not argue its necessity in the educational process.  How else can one know where to proceed next in lesson planning and instruction if there is no progress check on the concepts previously taught?  I get it.

            But I also know that assessment encompasses much more than paper/pencil tests.  A teacher can employ a variety of assessments all in one day which will give a more detailed, more accurate, more FAIR evaluation of the progress of their students.  One-on-one conferences with students, teacher observations, student presentations, essays, student demonstrations, exhibitions, portfolios, journals, individual and group projects, small group tutoring, homework, quizzes...and so many other options...exist to give teachers a much clearer picture of the ability levels of their children. 

            But these methods are not as "clean" as standardized testing.  They take time.  They vary from classroom to classroom, from student to student.  They are individualized.  They happen throughout the school year - everyday - not just during special weeks that remove ten hours away from the learning process. 

            Believe me, I get it.  Standardized tests can provide a quick barometer of a student's reading, writing, and 'rithmetic knowledge base.  It's quick (well, ten hours...) and it is intended to extract the same type of  information from every child.  But this type of assessment only provides a snapshot of one moment in time and does not provide teachers and administrators with an overall picture of each child.  Skills, talents and qualities such as artistic expertise, athletic prowess, team-building, public speaking, social and emotional development, technology integration and authentic problem-solving, as well as subjects such as history, geography, civics, and science, are all too often IGNORED.  Sixteenth century standards revolving solely around a child's ability to read, write and "figure" are limited standards for twenty-first century children.

            The blackened bubbles on last week's computer sheets do not adequately (if at all) inform me of the thought processes or problem solving strategies of my students.  The quickly scanned graphite marks give no indication of the physical or emotional well-being of each child on testing day either.  A computer cannot assess these qualities, but a caring teacher most definitely can.

            For example:

            Miguel has spent most evenings during the past two weeks with his mother and father, visiting his dying grandmother in the hospital.  He valiantly attempted and completed all tests this past week.  On Friday, after finishing his language assessment, he rested his head on his desk and fell fast asleep.  His scores for two of last week's tests earned him an "Approaching" label.

            Lizette came to school sick with the latest virus telling her mother she could not miss the test.  (She didn't make it through Thursday afternoon and stayed home Friday).  Her runny nose, coughing and sneezing affected this intelligent child's testing ability such that she received a "Falls Far Below" label in one subject and an "Approaches" label in another.  Who knows how much better the others at her table may have scored if they weren't distracted by Lizette's germs and related symptoms.

            Corrinne came to school clearly agitated Monday after having an argument that morning with her mother.  This young lady whose vocabulary greatly surpasses that of any other student, is now, as a result of her assessment, labeled "Approaches" in the area of writing.

            Lonnie, a behaviorally- and academically-challenged boy, rarely completes any assignment.  Numerous conferences with his mother and a multitude of interventions have yet to be effective in getting much of his work to my desk.  On Tuesday, as we were leaving for the day, Lonnie announced to his friend, "I just guessed on all of the questions."  He guessed well.  He has an "Exceeds" label in the area of reading. 

            The tests we took last week did not address such factors as fatigue, personal loss, sadness, illness, anger or stubbornness.  Yet, labels were assigned and interventions will be crafted to meet the needs of these and so many other children in accordance with the standardized test results achieved.

            And in April, we will test them again to see how much they learned.

(All student names have been changed).

Copyright, Tim Ramsey, 2014. 

This piece was originally submitted to our community forums by a reader. Due to audience interest, we’ve preserved it. The opinions expressed here are the writer’s own.

Share This Story

  • email icon

Filed Under

  • Assessment

Follow Edutopia

  • facebook icon
  • twitter icon
  • instagram icon
  • youtube icon
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

George Lucas Educational Foundation

Edutopia is a free source of information, inspiration, and practical strategies for learning and teaching in preK-12 education. We are published by the George Lucas Educational Foundation, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization.
Edutopia®, the EDU Logo™ and Lucas Education Research Logo® are trademarks or registered trademarks of the George Lucas Educational Foundation in the U.S. and other countries.