George Lucas Educational Foundation
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Share

I am addicted to searching for inspiring writing prompts. Like playing Pachinko, clicking through education resources soothes and focuses me. My coffee goes cold as I hunt through Twitter and Diigo posts for just one more idea. But for a few years now, guilt has bled some joy from my ritual of collecting writing warm-ups to try out with students.

For the sake of explanation, guess what perturbs me about the four writing prompts that I assigned this semester:

Prompt 1: Create a poem by using Emily Dickinson's "Bring me the Sunset in a Cup" as a springboard. (Creative Writing Prompts)

Prompt 2: After the instructor spreads eight fall leaves on a table (potatoes work, too), students secretly pick one and write about their "new best leaf friend." After each writer reads his or her composition, classmates guess which leaf their peers described.

Prompt 3: Use Five Card flickr, a web site and tool invented by Alan Levine that generates random images, to Dadaistically incorporate into a narrative. (Tom Barrett's 55 Interesting Ways to Support Writing in the Classroom)

Prompt 4: Students write a parody of Rod Serling's opening narration of The Twilight Zone, using the following scaffold:

The _________________________ Zone

There is a fifth dimension beyond that which is known to _____. It is a dimension as _____ as _____ and as _____ as _____. It is the _____ between _____and _____, between _____and _____, and it lies between the _____ of _____, and the _____ of his/her _____. This is the dimension of _____. It is an area that we call ... The _____ Zone. (Original source of the prompt unknown)

As an example of how the Twilight Zone parody works, see how "Melissa" completed this assignment. Note that she intentionally skipped the title so that there would be a bigger payoff at the conclusion of her passage:

"There is a fifth dimension beyond that which is known to man. It is a dimension as challenging as quantum physics and as rewarding as a winning slot machine. It is the balancing act between first steps and first heartbreaks, between achievement and disappointment, and it lies between the excitement of awaiting his birth and the angst of his departure to college. This is the dimension of unconditional love. It is an area that we call...the motherhood zone."

In response to each prompt, my students wrote and read aloud their work. There was laughter and applause, but I was still dispirited. You've probably guessed why.

Not all prompts are created equal

Alas, all four prompts from the list above were teacher generated one-shot exercises, culminating in disposable texts. I'm losing faith in clever prompts that culminate in clever, but what I suspect is, for students, ultimately forgettable writing.

Judith A. Langer and Arthur N. Applebee's research concludes that superficial writing activities offer superficial benefits. In contrast, when students are given time to manipulate complex information, their retention and understanding of content is enriched. In all the cases above, students were given little time to do more than what they do all day, follow instructions.

In Dan Rothstein and Luz Santana's new book, Making Just One Change: Teach Students to Ask Their Own Questions, the authors argue that because their instructors ask the majority of questions during a school day, kids are deprived of opportunities to generate their own questions about the cultural, political, philosophical, economic and scientific dimensions of a topic. Students are more likely to fully commit to the difficult process of critical thinking when they care about -- when they develop -- their own questions.

Check out this episode of Harvard EdCast where Rothstein and Santana talk about their six-step protocol for socializing students into thinking deeply about a topic and asking significant questions. If you like Edward de Bono's PMI, you'll like the six-step protocol. See Facing History and Ourselves for a summary and description of how a similar question formulation technique is employed in a classroom setting.

Last week, I tried out a slightly modified version of the six-step question generation procedure in an undergraduate English education class. In 40 minutes, the activity organically deepened my students' understanding of grammar instruction before I provided any content knowledge on the topic. One group of students asked this formidable question: "How do you teach students standard American English and academic language and still preserve native/cultural ways of speaking and writing?"

Such classroom experiences, where I resist controlling the "horizontal and vertical" of student writing, accompany my waning enchantment with take-and-bake prompts.

Was this useful?

Comments (5) Sign in or register to comment Follow Subscribe to comments via RSS

Monica Bruder's picture
Monica Bruder
Teacher of the Handicapped, Hamilton Township, New Jersey

Hello Todd,
Thank you so much for all of the creative writing prompt ideas! I am looking forward to using them with my students.
Monica Bruder

Tamara Doehring's picture

I always love your articles but rarely respond. This one hits a resounding chord with me. I work with teachers all over Florida and workshop this same idea. I suggest there is a difference between a prompt and a topic. We so often call the writing topic we provide "prompts" but really we are giving our student topics.
This happens most often when teachers only assign test "prompts" or reading-based "prompts." I see a prompt as a way of giving students something to work with in order to generate their own topic.
I provide one word prompts often: blue, 38, hunger....
Each of these require students to generate their own topics. To help direct the writing into a form, each prompt does not become a complete piece, but a brainstorm. This is another missed step in the process...
We also foucs on one genre a week--so using blue, 38, hunger... the students will be writing a personal essay. This means the prompts should generate something personally relating to them.
I also use images a lot, too. Thanks, Todd, for another honest article.
Tamara Doehring
The English Teacher's Friend

selenology's picture

I love *creating* writing prompts -- it's one of the most challenging parts of being an English teacher. My students don't do much writing like the five assignments at the beginning of your post, but I think a sprinkling of "superficial" ones is a good idea. They are playful and fun -- and having that experience of writing can be very significant for students who dread and loathe essays and other more-complex projects.

Denise M. Cassano's picture
Denise M. Cassano
Artist, Educator, Dog Lover

Love your insight. We have to be careful to not do the work for them, or verbally lead them in a particular direction. This is one of the reasons I make my illustrations and turn them into fine art video writing prompts. The critical thinking questions that work with the illustrations and videos are open ended and focus the child's observation. I think teachers need to reflect on what they are asking and how. I can't tell you the divergent answers I get when I show them fine art, because when you interpret it, you bring all of your life experience to it. All of us have had different experiences, and that's what makes art the perfect writing prompt.

Sign in to comment. Not a member? Register.