A Tale of Two Letters: Collecting Data and the Courage to Go Gradeless

April 19, 2016

Consider the following scenario. In an effort to make learning, not grades, the emphasis in his classroom, a teacher is proposing that next year he will give every kid an “A” in his class, no matter what, essentially taking grades off the table. Write a letter to this teacher evaluating and judging his proposal.  In addition, indicate how  you would personally respond to this approach if you were a student in his class next year.

It was the best of decisions. It was the worst of decisions...

Of course, Dickens was not talking about education here, but he could have been...Either way, it speaks to me now.

Nothing before me..., except a decision. Of course, it would be disingenuous to claim that my mind was not made up prior to my having the kids write their letters. I knew where I was going. I just wanted to gather some student input along the way. And, even if I had not already made my decision, I would have had to anyway based on the data (see below).

I shared Isaac and Meghan's letters because they represent the divide that I face, the ends of the spectrum. Both make relevant, valid points. In fact, each astutely represents his and her respective camp: "good idea" and "bad idea." And although I get what each is saying, I lean to Isaac's side. What's interesting about Isaac's letter is that it is the only essay that he has turned in on time--all year. In fact, it may be the only assignment he has turned in on time (although he eventually gets them in). I have to believe that this speaks to motivation on some level. When people are truly motivated, they will contribute. I believe Isaac would be more fully and deeply engaged in my class next year and maybe hate it less, making greater contributions not only to his own learning but also the community's.  Meghan, on the other hand suggests that she would be less-engaged without grades, but she is so conscientious and such a hard worker that I believe she would fully and deeply engage in my class next year--without the grades. It's just who she is. In short, I believe the new approach will not harm the Meghans of the world. But, and this is a big but here, folks, I believe with all my heart that the new approach might truly help the Isaacs of the world. In fact, I'm betting the farm on it. And while I had made up my mind prior to seeking input, I did listen to the kids. Always listen to the kids.

What the data revealed. Good Idea = 42%. Bad Idea = 38%. Good and Bad Idea = 20%. Essentially, then, my initial analysis is that, among the kids, it's a wash. I expected as much. I also expected, or rather, was not surprised by their reasons, reasons which reflect the rationale in each of the letters above. For the "good idea" kids, they generally pointed to less stress, more emphasis on learning, etc. For the "bad idea" kids, they mostly brought up fairness, kids taking advantage, kids not doing anything, and so on. Again, nothing I didn't anticipate and things I will certainly consider as I move forward with my decision, a decision that will no doubt seem wise to some and foolish to others. Decisions, indeed.

Originally published at

This piece was originally submitted to our community forums by a reader. Due to audience interest, we’ve preserved it. The opinions expressed here are the writer’s own.

Share This Story

  • email icon

Filed Under

  • Assessment

Follow Edutopia

  • facebook icon
  • twitter icon
  • instagram icon
  • youtube icon
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
George Lucas Educational Foundation
Edutopia is an initiative of the George Lucas Educational Foundation.
Edutopia®, the EDU Logo™ and Lucas Education Research Logo® are trademarks or registered trademarks of the George Lucas Educational Foundation in the U.S. and other countries.