Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation

I notice several students listening to music while busy at work. I have no good reason to ask that they remove their headphones and turn off their devices. As I walk around the room, I admire the elegant, concise prose each produces.

I ask one student why music helps her concentrate. "It soothes me and makes me less stressed," she says. "Plus, Ed Sheeran is just awesome."

As a college student, I spent countless hours studying in a dark corner of the Brandeis University Library. Often, I would lose track of time and wonder about seeing the sun again. Once, my mother called to ask why I hadn't yet returned home for Thanksgiving. I had forgotten about the holiday, focused on getting a jump-start on a major history paper while listening to Bruce Springsteen's "Thunder Road" on repeat.

Placing aside the issue of my self-induced exile, for me as well, music offered not only comfort but also increased focus -- or so I thought, at least until coming across the work of Dr. Nick Perham, a lecturer in the School of Health Sciences at the University of Wales Institute, Cardiff.

Impaired Performance

Perham's 2010 study, "Can preference for background music mediate the irrelevant sound effect?", shows how music can interfere with short-term memory performance.

I recently spoke with Perham, who told me about the "irrelevant sound effect." This involves a subject conducting a certain task, in this case recalling a series of numbers, while listening to different kinds of background music. If sound exhibits acoustical variations, or what Perham calls an "acute changing-state," performance is impaired. Steady-state sounds with little acoustical variation don't impair performance nearly as much.

I'm also interested by another of Perham's conclusions. "We found that listening to liked or disliked music was exactly the same, and both were worse than the quiet control condition," he says. "Both impaired performance on serial-recall tasks."

Still, I'm curious how prevalent serial-recall is in everyday life, and if one could get by without developing this skill. Unlikely, Perham says, as one would have tremendous difficulty recalling phone numbers, doing mental arithmetic, and even learning languages.

"Requiring the learning of ordered information has also been found to underpin language learning. If you consider language, learning syntax of language, learning the rules that govern how we put a sentence together, all of these require order information . . . " Perham says.

Perham asked his subjects how they think they performed when exposed to different tastes in music. Each reported performing much worse when listening to disliked music, although the study's results showed no difference.

I presented Perham's findings to my students, many of whom still refused to accept that listening to music while studying impairs performance. I even gave one of these otherwise bright and thoughtful individuals early access to my podcast interview with Perham.

"I enjoy listening to music while doing math," she says. "It really helps me think, and I won't stop listening even with the results of this study."

Silence is Golden

My student is mistaken, but Perham explains that she should listen to music before getting to work, to engage what's known as the "arousal and mood effect." In fact, as long as she does something enjoyable before hitting the books -- whether it's listening to music or doing anything else -- past studies have shown that this can produce the same positive effect on performance.

I ask Perham then about the so-called "Mozart effect," which, in one early experiment, gave individuals who had recently listened to the famous classical composer enhanced spatial-rotation skills. When they stopped listening and were asked to cut and fold paper, they performed better than when listening to something else.

"Subsequent studies suggested that this wasn't correct," Perham says.

Instead, improved performance had more to do with the preference of sound one listened to before engaging in such work.

"They found it if you like listening to Stephen King's stories," Perham says. "It wasn't anything to do with classical music or Mozart, it was to do on whether you liked [listening to] something or not."

In one of his more recent studies, Perham says, he found that reading while listening to music, especially music with lyrics, impairs comprehension. In this case, it's spoken lyrics, not acoustical variation that impairs productivity.

"You've got semantic information that you're trying to use when you're reading a book, and you've got semantic information from the lyrics," Perham says. "If you can understand the lyrics, it doesn't matter whether you like it or not, it will impair your performance of reading comprehension."

In conducting my own little experiment, I decided to write this article in complete silence. These days, I write while listening to Dave Matthews, John Mayer and other "chill" music. I'm not sure if or how this fits exactly into Perham's findings, but I finished writing in about half the time it normally takes me for something of this length.

At the very least, here's to hoping that my experiment will entice my students to also give it a try.

Editor's note: A PDF transcript of David Cutler's interview with Dr. Nick Perham is available on Spin Education, where this post originally appeared.

Comments (22)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

iamwave's picture
iamwave
let's revolve

Your point of view is half right, but half complete wrong.

Dr. Rob Garcia's picture
Dr. Rob Garcia
Former High School Engineering Teacher now Author and EdD

David,
GREAT article. Thank you for such a well thought out subject. While working on my Doctoral dissertation, I realized that my best focus was attained during listening to non vocal classical and jazz.

In layman's terms, if someone was talking or singing, my brain wanted to listen and absorb their thoughts.

You'll catch a lot of differing views because everyone processes differently, but I think you should be commended for addressing a topic bravely.
Dr. Rob

Dr. Rob Garcia's picture
Dr. Rob Garcia
Former High School Engineering Teacher now Author and EdD

Dr. Curwin,
Thanks for the great questions, I was fascinated by David's article. I have only written two books but music played an IMMENSE role in them.

Dr. Rob

David Cutler's picture
David Cutler
High School History, Government and Journalism teacher from Boston
Blogger 2014

Dear Dr. Rob,

Thank you for your comments and insight. I'm also a fan of jazz, and I do think there is something to be said while working and listening to music without lyrics. I'll have to do some more digging on that front. Indeed, I am catching a lot of different views, but I welcome freindly debate. I wish politicans, on either side of the aisle, could argue as amicably.

Once more, thank you for your kind note. It means a lot.

David Cutler's picture
David Cutler
High School History, Government and Journalism teacher from Boston
Blogger 2014

Thank you for your comment. I would be curious to hear what's "half complete wrong" with my perspective.

Best,

David

Lorrie Morales's picture
Lorrie Morales
Intermediate Science Teacher for private school in Puerto Rico

I, personally, cannot listen to music while performing any task that requires concentration. But I do have students that need to listen to music to concentrate better when given a physical task to do, but when they need to read, some prefer not to listen to music.
This can be a very interesting experiment to do with students in the classroom and it can help kids understand until what point it can be beneficial to listen or not music, or what kind of music they can listen when performing different tasks.

KKG Music's picture
KKG Music
Music Teacher/Chorus; Soprano Atlanta Symphony Orchestra Chorus

As with any study there are probably too many variables. As a musician I am completely distracted by almost any & every sound. Were it possible for me to "sit in silence" and focus then I do believe that perhaps short term retention might improve. However, I am sitting here, the vent is clicking because the heat is on, there is a plane flying overhead, I can hear my child typing on her computer down the hall in the music room, etc. A single piece of music playing allows me to focus. Of course, I'm useless at phone numbers. That's why smartphones were invented, yes? *wonders how many musicians were observed* #wearenotallthesame

AquiAmigo's picture

The study cited in this article actually didn't come to the generalized result described here and by the study author. The study only proved that listening to Lady Gaga, Rihanna and Arcade Fire (or similar pop music) would impair one's ability to memorize a series of numbers read by a computer-generated voice. Duly noted. I will never listen to Lady Gaga when trying to memorize numbers read to me by a computer-generated voice.

(1)
Tom Sullivan's picture
Tom Sullivan
Father of 3 in Los Angeles, CA

I do like to listen to music, especially if the alternative is background noise that I don't like, but I do agree with some of the specifics in the article.

I have always stayed away from music with lyrics (instrumental jazz & classical) when i want to study/work well.

Likewise I find it's best to listen to music with less "acute changing state" (term in the article), like ambient and minimalist classical (Glass, Reich).

frank's picture

Listening to music while reading helps to engage more areas of my brain and enhance focus. I also make deeper connections within the material more quickly than I would without music. I am concerned that the few studies on the issue have not considered enough intelligence or personality subtypes to effectively answer the question.

AquiAmigo's picture

The study cited in this article actually didn't come to the generalized result described here and by the study author. The study only proved that listening to Lady Gaga, Rihanna and Arcade Fire (or similar pop music) would impair one's ability to memorize a series of numbers read by a computer-generated voice. Duly noted. I will never listen to Lady Gaga when trying to memorize numbers read to me by a computer-generated voice.

(1)

Sign in and Join the Discussion! Not a member? Register to join the discussion.