Comments (14)

Comment RSS
Mike Coon (not verified)

Creating a sense of wonder

Was this helpful?
0

Tony,
I teach at a school in small rural town in Montana. I am fortunate to be part of a team that shares and encourages the type of educational experience you are talking about. I’m interested in reading more about your experiences. It’s definitely a struggle to balance and “implement meaningful, project-based, reality-based opportunities for children,” while making sure all students are becoming good test takers and succeed at standardized test. I’m looking forward to hear what you do in your district to find that balance.
Mike

Cathy Arfuso (not verified)

I agree with you on the

Was this helpful?
0
I agree with you on the topic of learning and children. In order for children to learn they need to be active participants in the learning process. For this to happen, the teacher needs to engage the children and connect meaning to their everyday lives. Only when learning is meaningful do children really understand and grow, not only in their academic life but also in their personal life. I always heard about constructivist learning but never really thought long and hard about it until this semester. Being in a classroom has shown me that students need a teacher who will give them the proper tools in order to succeed in life. Anyone can read from a textbook and memorize but it takes more than that to really understand. A little effort from an effective teacher can really take a child a long way.
Hannah MacLaren (not verified)

Adding to the commentary, I

Was this helpful?
0
Adding to the commentary, I want to add some thoughts, based on years of being a k-8 school principal: we did not have 'homework' per se, but rather expectations that students, once they read with a modicum of comprehension (roughly age 8), that they would read at home for 30 minutes to an hour each day from a book of their choice. Homework was 'work that went home', meaning if they were revising a paper or prepping for a math quiz, or preparing a presentation (science, social studies, etc.) there were usually not enough hours in the time at school to complete the work, and thus it went home (homework). We also worked with families to have their children take increasing (and appropriate) amounts of responsibility at home: for one instance, there was an expectation that when kids were 10 years old, they would prepare (from scratch) a meal each week for their family (and their responsibility included clean-up). We did a lot of cooking (note the maths/science/social studies possibilies) at the school. The point is that there are numerous ways to create seamless authentic connections in the lives of engaged students between school and home/community. Our problem was not stimulating curiosity; rather responding to it. A new kind of teacher exhaustion.
David Zavracky (not verified)

Being neither a parent nor a

Was this helpful?
0
Being neither a parent nor a teacher, my viewpoint resides solely in the realm of experiences as a student. I have no motivations for what I expect for my child and I don't hold personal desires as to how I would prefer my teaching job to be. I just have thoughts on what might have been. We all sat in front of teachers for twelve years. We had good ones and we had not so good ones. When we reflect on the experience, we know who they were. Over the years, a teacher should gain a perspective on what works and what does not work for different types of learners. Maybe some do and some don't and that's the difference between the good and not so good teacher. Maybe to some extent, the failure of the student is the failure of the teacher. The act of letting kids be kids and at the same time nurturing a learning environment can not be an easy one and I salute those of you attempting to make the change. If the effort towards good schools becomes focused on how to reach different learners by providing a positive learning experience, as Tony Bencivenga suggests and also instituted in his school, then I think you may be on the way to improving schools. David Zavracky Rockaway, NJ
Tony Bencivenga (not verified)

Nicholas, Your high and low

Was this helpful?
0
Nicholas, Your high and low ropes course sounds exciting and meaningful. Your concepts of engagement, safety, choice, and structure are absolutely relevant, clear, and useful. All of them are essential to nurturing a child-centered school community. My sense is that your program gives children a role in their learning. There is no doubt that quantifying "the value of classroom culture" is difficult; but, we can find hard data in the academic success of students and in their ability to solve problems both individually and cooperatively. As I've suggested, children who are given meaningful, reality-based tasks (similar to those you present in your course) "own" their work and are more likely to translate content knowledge and skills to all subject areas. The transference you seek will happen. In addition, children who are engaged, explore, and thrive on a range of challenging opportunities will have lots of anecdotal data to support your efforts. I applaud your vision of bringing the adventure-based program into the classroom setting. It's another way to enhance the school community that seeks to integrate imagination and academic success. Tony Bencivenga
Tony Bencivenga (not verified)

Brad, There is certainly a

Was this helpful?
0
Brad, There is certainly a place for homework for Mia in the school community of which I speak. I would hope that teachers would recognize Mia's passion for math problems, spelling words, and a book report. HER joy must be respected and valued. It would be wonderful to capture her interest and continue to engage her. As I said, there is no dichotomy between imagination and academic success. Both take many forms, all of which have a place in the school community. Tony Bencivenga
Jessica Martini (not verified)

As a former student of Tony,

Was this helpful?
0
As a former student of Tony, I have to say that I am incredibly excited to see where his series of blogs leads. In class, Tony instilled in me and my fellow graduate students the inspiration to strive to be enriching, engaging, exciting teachers. In a political-educational climate that tends to work against the ideals that Tony champions, it is refreshing and motivating to know that some educators resist the urge to give in and push to change this climate, one class at a time. I look forward to reading his suggestions and my future students will be the luckier for it.
James Manco (not verified)

I applaud Mr. Bencivenga for

Was this helpful?
0
I applaud Mr. Bencivenga for his belief that we need to meet the social/emotional needs of all our students in a caring and nurturing learning environment. I am also a big supporter on reality-based and project based learning activities. His belief that "education involves preparing students for the tests of life, and not a life of tests" is so true. We hear all too often the comment "I need to teach to the test". As educators we can find ways to prepare our students for these standardized tests through reality based and project based activities. As a future administrator, I am excited to read more on his thoughts on creating a learning environment where children are supported, cared for, and their social/emotional well being are being met. Incorporating parents and the community at large into the social and emotional learning environment is also an aspect where I feel is important and would like to learn more about.
Dave Scozzaro (not verified)

Currently going through my

Was this helpful?
0
Currently going through my graduate work, this is what I hope to achieve not as my educational philosophy, since it already is, but how to practically implement this into the classroom. I previously worked ina school that would have little to do with this. Lecture was the way to go. The only way to go. After only two years it was really eating away at my teaching experience and style and I'm hoping through my graduate experience, I can merge what I had planned in my head as an undergrad with what I can actually accomplish after attaining my masters. Thanks for the inspiration.
Nicholas Hagemann (not verified)

Tony and the other

Was this helpful?
0
Tony and the other respondants, It is great to find an avenue for this discourse. Many of the themes in the opening post and the responses relate to the project that I am currently working on. I work through Northern Arizona University running the NAU Challenge Course (a high and low ropes course running one day programs for many schools). I am working on bringing the adventure-based program that we run into the classroom setting. One of my main arguements for this transference is the creation of a vibrant classroom culture. I have isolated four keys elements of a classroom that all students desire and need to create a positive learning environment. Active Engagement- One of the biggest challenges to teaching is keeping the students actively engaged in relevant activities. Your task is not to keep the students busy but rather provide opportunities that draw the students in, create an atmosphere of play and serve a purpose. Safe Environment- Your students need to feel that they are in a safe environment both physically and emotionally. The environment that is created in your classroom needs to structured so that every student takes responsibility for the safety of themselves and the safety of the others in the group. Power of Choice- Students want the ability to decide if an activity is not appropriate for their goals. Experiential education is rooted in an idea that students need to make a choice to participate (be internally motivated) rather than be coerced or told to participate. (be extrinsically motivated) Although it may be difficult to establish the students' ability to make intrinsically driven choices, once they have taken on this responsibility, they will possess a tool that is very valuable. Clear Guidelines- Although they may complain and argue about "rules," children need guidelines that will determine if an action is appropriate or not. A lack of structure will lead to a lack of learning. Now comes the part where I need your opinions and help. Are these key elements relevant, useful and clear? How do we quanitify the value of classroom culture? Thanks for your time and your thoughts. Nicholas Hagemann NAU Challenge Course Flagstaff, AZ
see more see less