Texting in the Classroom: Not Just a Distraction | Edutopia
Edutopia on Facebook
Edutopia on Twitter
Edutopia on Google+
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

Texting in the Classroom: Not Just a Distraction

Audrey Watters

Education technology journalist
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Share

The Pew Research Center released new data this week on Americans' text-messaging habits. According to Pew, 83 percent of American adults now own cell phones and almost three-quarters (73 percent) send and receive text messages. The research only looks at adults' usage of text-messaging, but it does find that younger adults are much more active texters than older age groups. Cellphone owners between the ages of 18 and 24 exchange an average of 109.5 messages a day -- that's more than 3200 messages per month. That's compared to about 41.5 messages a day for all cellphone owners, a figure that's largely unchanged from figures reported in 2010.

The Pew study doesn't look at the texting habits of those under age 18, but a study released last year by Nielsen found that those cellphone users in the 13 to 17 age range were the most avid texters among any age group. According to this 2010 Nielsen data, people 18 to 24 sent an average of 1630 texts per month -- about half the number Pew says this group currently sends. And that Nielsen report pegged the texting rate of 13 to 17 year olds at 3339 per month -- approximately what 18 to 24 year olds are now sending and receiving. One might wonder: does the texting rate of 13 to 17 year olds continue to be twice that?

Certainly that age group -- in fact, all those under 18 -- are increasingly likely to be cellphone owners. According to those surveyed as part of Project Tomorrow's 2010 Speak Up report (PDF), more than half of middle and high school students (51 percent and 56 percent respectively) own a cell phone (without Internet access). In addition, 34 percent of middle schoolers and 44 percent of high schoolers own a smart phone.

With the ubiquity of cellphones, many schools are facing questions about what to do when students bring cellphones to school. Ban them outright? Require they be kept in a locker or backpack? Require they be turned off? Allow them to be used, at teachers' discretion, in class?

The reasons why cellphones are banned are, interestingly enough, many of the same things that make cellphones a potentially very useful educational tool: cellphones, particularly smart phones, are powerful mobile computing devices. If the cellphones have Internet access, students can use them to look up information online. Cellphones double as calculators and as cameras. And unlike iPads, e-readers, tablets, smart phones, laptops or desktop PCs, these devices are ubiquitous. Moreover, as the statistics indicate, text-messaging seems to be the preferred method of communication of teens.

The popularity of text-messaging has long been given as one of the main reasons why cellphones are a distraction in the classroom. If students are texting, they're not paying attention. Texting is often viewed as the new form of passing notes in the back of the class.

The assumption is, of course, that this SMS communication is always off-topic. But a variety of new tools have been released recently that are tapping into the popularity of texting and the ubiquity of cellphones and are demonstrating that these can, in fact, be used for educational purposes:

Remind: Remind allows teachers to send text messages (and email) home -- to students and/or to parents -- to offer reminders and updates for class. Remind allows teachers to communicate with their classes without either teacher or students having to share their phone numbers.

Poll Everywhere: As the name suggests, Poll Everywhere allows teachers to use cellphones for polling in class. Students text their responses, using their cellphones to give feedback, answer questions, take quizzes.

Celly: Celly provides SMS-based group messaging. Classrooms can use the service to take quick polls and quizzes, filter messages, get news updates, take notes, and organize and hold study groups. The groups can be public or private, moderated or open.

StudyBoost: StudyBoost allows students to study via SMS-based quizzes. The questions can be self- or teacher-created, and can be multiple choice or open-ended.

Of course, the availability of these tools does not mean that all cellphone usage is de facto educational and that all texting in class is on-topic. As with any technology, cellphones do require policies for acceptable use, and students need guidance on exactly what that means. But these new tools do give educators a range of options should they decide to let students turn their cellphones on in class. Many of these tools have been designed with the classroom setting in mind, and have privacy policies, moderation features, and analytics so that teachers can feel more confident in how texting is being utilized.

But most importantly, perhaps, with cellphones becoming increasingly ubiquitous, text- messaging tools are less likely than smartphone or even Web apps to exclude some students because they don't have access to the latest technology.


Comments (14)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Jim Berman's picture
Jim Berman
Chef Instructor working with 10th, 11th & 12th graders; Wilmington, DE

Cell phone use in class can be an effective, relevant medium. Yet, so many educators are reticent to even consider the platform, let alone embrace it. It strikes me that proverbially burying one's head in the sand over cell phone usage is not unlike alienating calculator users twenty-five years ago or ball point pen usage in class fifty years go. PollEverywhere has been a long-employed staple in my classroom; what a fantastic way to allow students a little of that 'angst relief' of not being able to text while incorporating an assessment tool that is effective and energizing. Seems to me that we need to move forward and not dwell on a past when information only came from books and worksheets.

scrivener's picture
just a teacher

It's difficult for teachers to embrace students' use of these phones in the classroom because it's tough to let go of control. However, Pew Research also revealed that students in schools with restrictive cell-phone-use policies and students in schools with liberal cell-phone-use policies were spending the same amount of time on their cell phones. Texting is too important a part of young people's lives: we can try to wedge ourselves between them, but that's a losing battle.

Teaching students responsible use, even if that use is NOT as relevant to whatever's going on in the classroom as with the examples in this article, seems to be a must. I tell my students to keep their phones on the desks in front of them. When a call or text message comes in, they are encouraged to give it a quick look and to assess whether or not that's a good moment to send a reply. The grownups around them (including all their teachers) do the same thing multiple times a day. Most of us have learned to manage the technology; why aren't we teaching THEM to manage it the same way?

Rebecca Gruber's picture

It seems like a case of "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em." Utilizing the tools and devices the students are familiar with is another route for teachers to use as apart of education. I know I find it easier (and often more enjoyable) to learn and work with devices I am already used to using. Technology use in school does not have to be limited to computers, tvs, etc. As most students nowadays do have phones, teachers should take advantage of the "free" access they have to communicate and work with the students via the suggestions above and other options they may come up with on their own.
I agree with the above comment on helping students to responsibly use the technology. If teachers would be willing to show their students how to determine when and where are good opportunities for cell phone usage, there might be less of a paranoia about phones in school.

Suzy Gurton's picture
Suzy Gurton
Education Manager at the Astronomical Society of the Pacific

I understand the, "if you can't beat them" mentality, but are cell phones really ubiquitous if only half of the students own them? If you're building their use into the curriculum, how do the half who don't have phones participate? I have 2 teens with cell phones, but they have several friends who don't and they have a very restrictive policy at their school, so they have several friends who have had theirs confiscated.

I know my daughter is suffering from inconsistent policies within her high school math department regarding graphing calculators. She had one "old school" teacher who wanted them to know how do everything without the calculator and now has one that expects them to use a graphing calculator without having taught how to use one. I bring this up because with any technology, there has to consistent policies about their use and universal access for it to work.

blog 3 Edtech Myths

Last comment 3 days 11 hours ago in Technology Integration

Discussion Star Trek: Next Generation - Technology as an Accelerator

Last comment 3 days 8 hours ago in Classroom Technology

article New Teachers: Technology-Integration Basics

Last comment 1 week 5 days ago in New Teachers

Discussion CyberSafety: Mock it, Don't Block It

Last comment 2 days 5 hours ago in Bullying Prevention

blog Five-Minute Film Festival: 8 Podcasts for Learning

Last comment 3 weeks 6 days ago in Five-Minute Film Festival

Sign in to comment. Not a member? Register.