Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

Police Presence in Schools: A Social-Emotional Learning Perspective

Maurice Elias

Professor, Rutgers University Psychology Department and Edutopia Blogger

At a statewide forum on school safety sponsored by the NJ School Boards Association on January 18, 2013, more than 700 educational leaders discussed the issue of school safety and security in light of the unfathomable deaths in Sandy Hook Elementary School. Why it takes a tragedy to force us to think about things that were no less important the day before that tragedy, we can lament. But now, we must act, and act wisely.

The right question to ask is not simply about student safety. We must address the overwhelming wellbeing of our children and the climate and culture of the schools in which they spend 180 school days each year for so many years. I do not want to minimize the events in Newtown but children are most affected by what happens around them every day.

And every day, when children come to schools hungry, afraid of harassment, intimidation, or bullying, or of neighborhood violence, or if they are involved in alcohol or tobacco or other drug use, or if they are victims of unkindness, or consumed by their educators' anxiety over standards and standardized tests, they are not able to learn to their potential. It will be the unusual child who will worry every day about a crazed gunman breaking down the school door. And for every child who may be reassured by the presence of armed guards, more children are likely to be more anxious. That is the dilemma we face.

Ultimately, the decision about how to increase security in schools is political and financial. From a public health perspective, there is no clear way to prevent the kind of determined and well-armed intruder who seeks to do harm to children in or around schools. At the conference, Raymond Hayducka, the Chief of Police and Coordinator of the Emergency Management Office in South Brunswick, NJ, was highly articulate about the importance of ensuring that anyone with weapons in the school is highly trained and fully coordinated with the policy.

This only comes from having a police officer in the school or from a well-regarded security agency with known relationships with the police force in one's district. A retired officer or a private guard has no legal authority and the school has no assurance of how well versed they are in the current and ever-changing standards for dealing with armed intruders.

The Chief also spoke eloquently about how, if a decision is made to not have armed personnel in schools, it is wise to increase policy patrols around and in schools, as well as police involvement in emergency response and evacuation plans, including the conduct of a security audit.

Helping Students Understand More Police Presence

From a social-emotional learning point of view, the question that looms is how do the inevitable increases in security, including greater police presence, affect children. It does not take special insight to realize that some kids will be put off, and others will hardly notice or, if they notice, will not care. A few are likely to feel a sense of reassurance. However, the greatest harm comes from not confronting the issues directly.

Handling changes in school safety procedures involves explicit, conversations with children and parents. Recognize first that for young children -- through elementary school -- the key goal is to provide reassurance. They should not have any sense of danger in their school and it is likely that the vast majority will have put the Sandy Hook shootings out of their minds.

For secondary students, the goal is to express prudent caution. Again, there should be no sense of imminent danger, but older students can be told that in light of Sandy Hook, the school wants to be extra careful and so certain steps are being taken. I believe this is the approach to take with parents, as well -- there is no reason to expect assault in the schools and so a measured, appropriate response is being taken to be on the side of reasonable safety.

But there is more -- from a SEL point of view. This is a tremendous learning opportunity to help children understand not only the role of the police in their lives, but other emergency services providers. These include firefighters, EMS technicians, and sanitation workers. If there is a greater police presence in the schools, ensure that this becomes a teachable moment and help students understand everything that police do, and invite other emergency service providers into the school to discuss what they do, walk around and be visible to students, and help all students understand that their safety in all respects is important. The community cares about them and they should appreciate this.

By so doing, we allow the focus to shift from security and danger to caring and concern. What happened in Newtown must not distract us from recognizing that the greatest safety for the greatest number of individuals comes from a safe, caring, supportive, academically challenging, healthy school culture and climate.

In such schools, students learn to be empathic to their classmates, including those who are different, and to be upstanders, not bystanders. They learn that violence is not a way to solve problems and they learn how to manage their strong emotions. These schools embrace students who are suffering from mental health difficulties, ensuring that they get needed services, and, should they drop out or otherwise leave, that they are followed.

A nurturing and positive school culture and climate provides the conditions that best allow schools to carry out their mission of educating children for success in school and life and preparing them to be responsible, productive, caring adult participants in their families, workplaces, and civic contexts.

Maurice Elias

Professor, Rutgers University Psychology Department and Edutopia Blogger
Related Tags:

Comments (4)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Melanie Link Taylor's picture
Melanie Link Taylor
Educational Consultant/Author, Southern California

In our state, most secondary schools are accustomed to police presence (at the very least the District type.) The elementary level students would need clear explanations at to the need for police. Our kids are not sheltered. They are aware of threats to their security. Technology (television included) has robbed them of childhood's peace and optimism. Kids need to know they are safe (the very basis of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs) but kids frequently are not safe at home, in the neighborhood or at school. More counseling and positive interventions should accompany the police presence. More playing to the positive aspects of their lives to encourage positive behavior, security and confidence in the future. Kids don't need to anticipate dystopia.

Dani's picture

Speaking as someone who is studying to be a teacher the prospect of doing so becomes more terrifying every time I turn on the news. In your section that talks about helping students understand more police presence I found myself being more reassured than I expected. I appreciate your post, although the idea of working in high schools where the pervasiveness of bullying and violence can be so all-encompassing, I find myself determined and deterred in equal measure.

alice ray's picture

I was inspired by Maurice's blog to consider what makes a school emotionally safe for kids. For some kids, school may be the only sanctuary that is safe from parents' physical or emotional abuse, from domestic violence, from neighborhood violence . . . and from the feelings of anger, shame and fear that accompany all that. A trend that worries me is well-intended intrusion by educators into the personal lives of children, inadvertently turning private pain into a public knowledge, under the guise of 360 group assessment of school difficulties. Let's keep schools physically safe for sure, but let's keep them emotionally safe as well, not only through promoting a positive school climate, but also by recognizing and respecting the role of schools as emotional sanctuary for many children.

Brangela West's picture

This was a great article. The incident at Sandy Creek was horrible and it will go down in history as a moment that made everyone with a heart stop what they were doing and pray for the families who lost their precious loved one. As a parent and educator I think more police presence in school is definitely needed. For some students school is a safe haven for them. There are some who get bullied to no end but for the most part school is where you can learn, eat, and have fun. Police presence can be very positive. They can show students what to do in case of an emergency. Students trust police officers so they will be more apt to listen to what they have to say. There are no Utopian societies. We have to teach our children how to survive just in case there's no one around to protect them. My heart and prayers go out to every family at Sandy Creek. As a nation and community we have to do something to prevent this from happening again.

Sign in and Join the Discussion! Not a member? Register to join the discussion.