Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

Glossing: How to Help Your Composition Students Think and Write About Revising (Guest Blog)

Today's guest blogger is Bob Alexander, a language arts consultant with the Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network (PaTTAN), in Harrisburg, PA.

No matter how much technology may change writing instruction, there will never be an advance sophisticated enough to replace the writing conference as the most effective formative assessment tool available for gauging students' writing progress, both overall, and specific to a current assignment. On the surface, Glossing is a simple revision technique that requires students to highlight changes to writing, but a closer examination reveals the depth and power Glossing can add to writing instruction, for both teachers and students. The great thing about Glossing is that it uses "innovative" technology to maximize time and effort.

As the result of a writing conference, someone is going to be writing and rewriting; it then follows that someone will be reading and rereading. This is old news for composition instructors, and often they have legitimate concerns about managing the paper load of multiple drafts. "Glossing" is a technique that streamlines the revision process for teachers and students, allowing for more effective conference time and focused assessment opportunities, more meaningful reflective writing and revision time, and less time wrangling with paper load.

Glossing: "Puttin' on the Ritz"

Generally, when a student finishes a writing conference, he/she has received feedback and is charged with revising the draft as discussed in conference. With the demands for assessment as well as progress in instruction, finding the time to revisit the draft as many times as is necessary to ensure leaning goals have been achieved may prove challenging. Having students put a "Gloss" on the paper is a quick and easy way for instructors to measure the growth and change of writing over multiple drafts.

The Glossing "How To's"

To put a "Gloss" on the paper, use the following process:

  • Carefully coach the student through the conference and make sure there is a process in place for notating and/or recording feedback. The students should always leave a conference understanding where they are in the writing process. Transparency is essential to progress.
  • The student utilizes feedback from the conference to revise the specific draft. On the revised draft, the students apply the following process:
  • 1. Either with a highlighter, or with the highlighter function in word processing, the student highlights the changes made from the previous drafts. In some cases, it may be a line or a sentence. In some cases, it may be an entire paragraph. Either way, it is important to highlight or "Gloss" any and all changes, even conventions.

    2. In the margins of the paper next to the glossed section or with an arrow pointing to the revisions, the student writes why they made the changes. If details were required to better illustrate an example, a student would write just that. "I added this detail to strengthen my example." This step is important because it requires a student not only to make revisions, but also to use the language of the revision process to illustrate understanding of why the change(s) were made. This understanding is essential for a student to take ownership of writing and move forward in the writing process, and it is important information for a teacher in assessing the next step(s) of the process and mastery of specific assignments.

    3. Students must turn in the "Glossed" draft along with the previous draft for teachers to review. The teacher can quickly browse the original draft, and then refer to the glossed draft to see the specific highlighted changes. A double check of the students margined explanation provides further evidence of the students understanding of the revision. It is not necessary to read the entire piece of writing, but rather, teachers can focus attention directly to the glossed portions of the piece.

    Benefits

    I have discovered these truths when using the process with consistency and fidelity:

    • Students learn and apply the "language of writing" which leads to metacognitive reflection and articulation. Making revisions and explaining the nature of those revisions and how they fit into the bigger picture of piece of writing creates a life-long-learning skill that is transferable to all content areas.
    • Combined with careful planning, conferencing, and instructional support, an instructor's paper load and reading time can be greatly reduced and streamlined. Remember, you do not have to read everything.
    • A "living" record of the writing process is preserved, and students have a concrete document that illustrates their own personal learning process. Students take possession of their learning and develop their own formative assessment skills.

      Of course, Glossing is not the end-all be-all of revision techniques, but it is a great tool for the teacher who uses conferencing in conjunction with other formative assessment techniques. As a regular part of coaching and instruction, glossing can save you time and engage students in taking an active part in the writing and revising process. Ok, so the technology utilized is not really "innovative", but it is practical and accessible. So, give it a whirl and have students get their gloss on!

      For Deeper Exploration on Glossing

      A lesson plan for Glossing from Learn NC

      The Glossing Process as a Practical Approach to Grammar Instruction

      A Different Take on Glossing

      Bob Alexander is a Consultant with the Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network (PaTTAN) in Harrisburg, Pa. Bob has also worked with the North Carolina Department of Public, and he has twenty years experience as a high school English Teacher. In addition, Bob is a member of the Paideia National Faculty.

Comments (6)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

researchpaper's picture

Thank you for the post. It is actually a technique I've been using since long time already and it brings results. Seeing what has been changed and why not only helps teacher evaluate the papers faster but also helps student see their brainstorm materialized and memorize what are the mistakes they made to avoid them in their next paper. I also sometimes practice a student presenting the best paper to the class showing the draft, the changes they've made and the final result to display the process of writing and critical evaluation.

Joe Raposa's picture

Spoken like a true English teacher. I find that writing conferences can make an enormous difference in student writing. This is a man that I believe we could all learn a lot from. Excellent work Mr. Alexander!

Glen Andersen's picture
Glen Andersen
Fifth Grade Teacher from Utah

Youmentn that the technology is not "innovative". We also need to remember that technology is not the "end all, be all" either. Great teaching includes all kinds of lessons that include glossing. Whatever it takes to help students learn and make their lives better is what we should be doing. Technology has it's place and is very useful, but does not beat the knowledge and innovation of a human teacher. Thank you for your strategy. This will help my students.

Laverne McLain's picture

What an absolutely wonderful idea! Students are so addicted to technology that writing, revising, editing and finally publishing is not the popular route. My students prefer to type the paper and turn it in quickly. The use of the "glossing" technique is an awesome way to hopefully get a better response. Additionally, the strategy will assist with the paper load. Thanks for sharing this great idea.

Richard Sinay's picture
Richard Sinay
Retired College and High School English Teacher

Writing conferences are great if you can mange to do them while 37 other students sit and wait for theirs. Despite the effort to conference, the management of the rest of the class is a daunting one. Even though they are "working" on the revision of their paper, they find time to get distracted whenever the teacher is conferencing with a student. So what is the solution? Conference with them all at the same time by learning to integrate the teaching of grammar and mechanics into the revision of a rough draft. Then all students are engaged with their own paper, and you "kill" 37 birds with one stone.

Discussion The Black Sheep of Teaching

Last comment 6 days 9 hours ago in Teacher Educators

blog Mastering the Teaching Game

Last comment 1 day 10 hours ago in Teaching Strategies

Discussion The Rookie Survival Kit: What to Buy for Your First Classroom

Last comment 1 week 7 hours ago in New Teachers

Discussion Advice on Where to Apply for Teacher Prep Student Teaching?

Last comment 1 week 6 days ago in New Teachers

Discussion Why I Became a Catholic School Teacher

Last comment 2 weeks 3 days ago in New Teachers

Sign in and Join the Discussion! Not a member? Register to join the discussion.