Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation

Mashable defines gamification as "applying game thinking or even game mechanics into a non-game context. " Game mechanics in the "real world" include earning badges, completing missions and leveling up. Non-game companies, like Amazon, Deloitte and Salesforce.com, gamify to increase customer engagement. Gamification puts the customer on a journey motivated by intrinsic, or personally meaningful, rewards. An example is earning a "mayorship" badge on the mobile application Foursquare by "checking in" regularly to the same location.

Gamification in the classroom has many benefits, too. After all, engaging a student intrinsically in the learning process, rather than with extrinsic motivators like grades, is the goal of every teacher. Awarding badges for academic accomplishments is a method to gamify the education. Global Kids, Inc. notes that badges "support learners to give language to and value what they are learning, by offering names for their new competencies and providing a venue that recognizes their importance."

As a teacher, I assumed that game design had more to do with coding than the study of human behavior. To truly understand gamification, I realized that I needed to understand the process of game design. In gaming terms, I decided to go on a quest.

Bartle's Player Types

Gamification dates back to the 1996 publication of Bartle's Player Types Model. Game designer and professor Richard Bartle created an x, y axis detailing four types of people that interact in virtual worlds. These include:

  • Killers: those who act against other game players
  • Achievers: those who build up their in-game status
  • Explorers: those who gather artifacts and look around
  • Socializers: those who build friendships

This model was originally intended for text-based multi-user dungeon (MUD) games that were popular in the 1990s (think Ultima II or Zork). MUDs predate multi-player online games with 3D graphics (like World of Warcraft). Much to Bartle's amusement, his model has been used as a template for non-game environments, like website design and social media platforms.

Social Engagement Verbs

Amy Jo Kim, Ph.D. is a leading consultant on gamification as a business model to increase customer engagement. She also holds a Ph.D. in behavioral psychology. In 2010, Kim reworked Bartle's Player Types Model. She replaced the "Killer" type with "Express" -- a much more business- and school-friendly descriptor! Completing the axis, "Compete" took the place of "Achiever," "Explore" replaced "Explorer," and "Collaborate" replaced "Cooperate."

Kim also added Social Engagement Verbs to her model. Social Engagement Verbs are reminiscent of Bloom's Taxonomy of higher-order thinking verbs. Here are some examples:

  • Express verbs: build, design, customize, choose, create
  • Competitive verbs: compare, win, challenge
  • Explore verbs: curate, review, rate
  • Collaborate verbs: comment, share, like (think social media)

Teachers, like game designers, can gamify by choosing a quadrant and then creating goals and objectives using Kim's Social Engagement Verbs.

Gamifying with Dr. Amy Jo Kim's Social Engagement Verbs

Credit: Amy Jo Kim, Ph.D.

Flow, Fun and Serious Fun

The psychological concept of "flow" is prevalent in game design. Dr. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, a pioneer in the field, defines flow as "the creative moment when a person is completely involved in an activity for its own sake." Csikszentmihalyi created a model, known as the "flow channel," to describe the environment where skill and difficulty increase just enough to ensure that an experience is neither frustrating nor boring. Examples of integrating flow into the classroom setting include allowing students to choose how they learn, providing hands-on challenges, and setting goals.

In addition to achieving flow, game players also seek to have fun. Dr. Kim observes that Bartle's Player Types Model has continual merit because "different people enjoy different types of fun." Fun, as it turns out, is serious business! In fact, the game publisher Valve (Portal, Half Life 2) employs a full-time experimental psychologist to measure players' physiological responses to game play.

Based on players' facial expressions, XEO Design founder Nicole Lazzaro described 4 Keys 2 Fun:

  1. Easy Fun (Novelty): Curiosity from exploration, role play and creativity
  2. Hard Fun (Challenge): Fiero, the epic win, from achieving a difficult goal
  3. People Fun (Friendship): Amusement from competition and cooperation
  4. Serious Fun (Meaning): Excitement from changing the player and their world

Nicole Lazzaro's 4 Keys 2 Fun

Source: XEO Design

In short, when gamifying, don't forget that it is supposed to be fun! (For more of Lazzaro's 4 Keys, watch her TED Talk.)

Examples

One of the more cohesive examples of a gamified learning environment is CodeAcademy. This organization teaches coding (JavaScript, HTML) and features badges, lessons to unlock the online world's mysteries, and (importantly!) fun activities with real meaning. There are even free PDFs and tools for after-school clubs.

ClassBadges is a website that enables teachers to award badges. For more on successful badge implementation, read "Six Ways to Look at Badging Systems Designed for Learning," a collaborative study initiated by Barry Joseph of Global Kids, Inc.

Thinking Like a Game Designer

In order to successfully gamify in the classroom, it is therefore important to think like a game designer. In the book Reality Is Broken, Jane McGonigal observes that "players begin each game by tackling the obstacle of not knowing what to do and not knowing how to play." In other words, players are encouraged to learn as they go. This is the heart of student-centered learning. My quest led me to the very definition of constructivism!

Comments (6)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Margarita Finkel's picture
Margarita Finkel
Social media for e-learning & technology

Surely, we should consider games as a great tool to get pupils interested in subject. Using games in school can be a hugely rewarding experience for children. They can learn a great deal about strategy, logic, effective communication with others and it can help their literacy and numeracy. But on some children it might have an adverse effect, therefore we should not forget about enjoyable alternative activity and offer it to children and teens. Here some links http://quib.ly/qu/are-games-addictive to websites which advice which games are suitable for different age group, reviews of current popular video and online games, etc.

Wowzers's picture
Wowzers
Wowzers offers online Game-based Math curriculum for Grades 3-8

Love the relation to Bartle's player types, Matthew. This line really gave us a kick too, "In short, when gamifying, don't forget that it is supposed to be fun!"

If anyone is seeking a gamified math learning experience, much like the fun ideas listed in this article, we'd love for you to take a free 21-day trial of our 3rd-8th grade game-based learning math content at www.wowzers.com/trial

Yu-kai Chou's picture
Yu-kai Chou
Gamification Pioneer and Regular Lecturer at Stanford University

Funny - I was just working on my book Actionable Gamification - Beyond Points, Badges, and Leaderboards when I saw this article.

I think you've done some great research here. One of the things that are good to look at is Octalysis (http://bit.ly/octalysis) as well as the more specialized player types by Andrzej Marczewski.

Also, consider checking out my post Top 10 Education Gamification Examples that will Change our Future: http://www.yukaichou.com/gamification-examples/top-10-education-gamifica...

Keep up the amazing work!

Anu Divakaran's picture

I must say some really good insights! Thanks for sharing it. I also happen to chance upon an interesting webinar coming up by Ross Smith, Director of Test Microsoft Skype Division on 12th September. Ross will be speaking about 'Where do serious games make the most sense?'. You might want to be a part of it. Here is the link to register for the session https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/613153649

Anu Nevalainen's picture
Anu Nevalainen
Former IT teacher and current adults' ICT trainer from Espoo, Finland

I was looking for ideas for my next blog post and happen to end up here. Great background study! I just realized myself that gamification can be used to motivate students and I was so excited about that. I had to write a blog post of my own so I could help others discover that as well (http://www.cloudriven.fi/en/blog/what-motivates-to-learn/). Now all we need to do is gamify our courses and motivate learners!

Sign in and Join the Discussion! Not a member? Register to join the discussion.