What Works in Public Education

Advertisement

The Edutopia Poll

by Sara Ring

Print Forward Share Comments(149) Comment RSS

The three-day weekend isn't just for the occasional holiday anymore. For one hundred school districts in at least sixteen states, the school week is now only four days long because the rising cost of fuel has made busing kids too expensive. Proponents of the shorter school week (which typically has longer daily hours to make up for the lost day) say it not only saves on fuel and energy costs but also often leads to lower rates of absenteeism and, in some cases, better student performance. Schools can also put the money they save toward programs and staff that might otherwise be cut. Opponents of the four-day week argue that it places a burden on working parents, who now need to find child care on the fifth day. They also say it cuts down on time for extracurricular activities. And those who'd like to see children spend more time in school worry that this practice moves education further away from that ideal. Do the merits of the four-day week outweigh the drawbacks? Tell us what you think!

Is the four-day school week good for education?

Yes. The four-day week is a workable solution to the budget crunch that schools face.
68% (815 votes)
Maybe. Schools should look at other ways to cut the budget before resorting to a four-day week.
12% (138 votes)
No. The ramifications of a four-day week, such as the need for parents to find child care and problems with extracurricular activities, outweigh the benefits.
18% (214 votes)
None of the above. (Comment below.)
2% (29 votes)
Total votes: 1196
0
was this helpful?
David Barrios
Posted on 9/09/2008 3:10pm

The School Year

This could potentially be great if the school year were lengthened. It gives the kids more time to complete assignments and less propensity for overload. This may also help retain new teachers as it eases the burden of jumping in by slowing the pace a little for them.

0
was this helpful?
Paul Abramson
Posted on 9/10/2008 3:05pm

Four-Day Week

None of the above because the question poses the educational value of the four-day week (which may or may not be a good idea -- for high school students it could be very good if the extra day was used on independent study or community service) against the societal implications (hardship for working parents). Schools -- especially elementary -- DO serve as "baby sitting" services, whether we want to admit that or not, so the Educational Values cannot be evaluated without referencing the Societal Problems a four-day week would cause, rendering all the simplistic responses posed to the original question, incorrect. Therefore, none of the above is the only answer thinking persons can give until the two problems are viewed together.

0
was this helpful?
Julie Smith
Posted on 9/10/2008 4:41pm

4-Day Work Week

My school system is on the 4-day week. We love it! There have been a few complaints from parents in the district (not my school!) about having to get their children to the daycare the system provides. Our school scores have gone up, and the district scores have not gone down. The 4-day week is a big draw for many of the teachers, because we can get our business, appointments and plans done on Monday, teach Tuesday-Friday, and devote the weekend to family.

0
was this helpful?
Shelley
Posted on 9/10/2008 6:26pm

Week

Kids should be in school 5 days a week.

Why should kids be in school 9 or 10 hours a day just to save money?
That is exactly the answer I would expect from bureaucrats, board members, and people who know nothing about child development.

0
was this helpful?
John C. Holoduek, Supervisor
Posted on 9/11/2008 6:57am

The Issues Alone May Make It Unworkable

Extending the school day, to accommodate five days in four, will impact all the good and important things which happen beyond the traditional school day, including off-hour alternative programs. States will have to accommodate the change in the legislated number of school days (in NJ, 180). It will not change contacted salaries, since what was accomplished in a five day week must equal the same work product, so the unions would have to fight strong. Schools would then, being good servants of the community, find some way for the fifth day to still have programming...and that would cost. These and all...the issues alone may make it unworkable. We would see a redistribution of days to lessen the impact of light and heat...or a rethinking of vacation and holiday time...before a four day school week.

0
was this helpful?
jeff haney
Posted on 9/11/2008 7:06am

21st Century Needs

To become a globally competitive nation, we must leave the agriculture based mindset of the 20th century and focus on the needs of the 21st century. Schools will need to become more fluid with their schedules and may possibly need to adapt to a modified year around schedule. If it necessary for us to incorparate a four day schedule then so be it. Do what's best for the children.

0
was this helpful?
Joan Sando
Posted on 9/11/2008 10:33am

4-Day School Week

Our charter school uses a four day week and 95% of the families express great satisfaction with the schedule on our annual surveys. Teachers have more time for preparation, collaboration, and professional development, so the students benefit. It is not a budgetary issue for us, but an educational issue.

0
was this helpful?
Julio Perez
Posted on 9/11/2008 1:54pm

Right To Choose

Leave it up to vote per district and/or school. Community calls for integration. With the money spent to provide FOOD THAT GETS THROWN AWAY DAILY because students do not eat ceirtain items from schools cafeteria food I wonder if we could pay more classroom Teacher Aids. At least feed so deserving teachers for free! Children need more one-on-one attention in 1 or 7 Days of school (if that were the case) and not so much laws that encorage but then prohibit. More Part time teachers are providing more parents at home more days of the week and perhaps healthier teachers with better attitude at ensuring teaching and not just instruction. If a student performs as well in a 4 day week but he wants more/no more school then let him/her have it and viceversa. Let's strenghten comunities by car pooling, meeting our neighbors, colaborating more, etc and we may save the rising "goods dependent" generation.

0
was this helpful?
S.Steelman
Posted on 9/11/2008 2:04pm

Unworkable Issues

It is imperative that we as a Nation do not lose the acquired knowledge of common sence and do every thing in our power to pass it on to our youth at least 5 days a week.

0
was this helpful?
Connie Spolar
Posted on 9/11/2008 2:40pm

The Four Day Week

I love the idea of a four day week. It would save a lot in fuel costs over the course of a school year, not only for the districts, but for teachers who must commute and it would lessen traffic congestion. Students would be "fresher" knowing they only have to be in school for 4 days. It would promote family fun without raising absenteeism by allowing parents to take a 3 day vacation that doesn't mean their student misses class. It means less days out for students who are sick also. Knowing they have 3 days to rest up might encourage parents to send their complaining student to school. I know that we don't want students here who really need to be home resting when ill, but honestly, we all know that many students stay home sick when they could have gone to school. Then the teacher has the extra work of getting their homework and missed classwork together (at least, we elementary school teachers do), and trying to "catch them up" on what-ever was taught when they were out. Considering how much homework highschool AP students have to do, it would provide them more time to finish and still allow for family time. My family has had many a Sunday when we could not have some "family time" due to the mountain of homework that had to be finished (often assigned on Friday, not a lot of lead time). The criticism that it makes life more difficult for working parents is invalid. The purpose of public education is not to provide free babysitting for working parents, however convenient it is. It is to provide students a quality education, which unfortunately in these current times, is affected by hard economic times. Districts have to look at all options of how to make their best of their budgets.

Post a comment

Sign in or create an account now, or after you post.

Sign In

Thanks for your comment. It will be posted once you've signed in to your account. Please sign in here
Not yet a member of the Edutopia community? Create an Account

Create an Account

Almost there! As soon as your account is created, your new comment will be posted.
Mollom CAPTCHA (play audio CAPTCHA)
By creating an account, you agree to Edutopia's terms of use.