What Works in Public Education

The Edutopia Poll

by Sara Ring

Print Forward Share Comments(11) Comment RSS

Like so many other aspects of education, gym class is going digital. At least several hundred schools across the country now incorporate into their fitness curriculums Dance Dance Revolution, a video game in which students mimic on-screen directions to perform intricate dance routines. West Virginia, which suffers one of the nation's highest obesity rates, intends to include the game in every public school by the end of the 2008-09 school year. Though no schools have entirely replaced standard activities, such as rope climbing, calisthenics, and the much-dreaded dodgeball, the popularity of digital fitness programs could sound the death knell for the traditional workouts that have defined PE. Is the kid-friendly, aerobic nature of digital fitness superior to activities that emphasize athletic ability, teamwork, and competition? Tell us what you think!

Do digital fitness programs beat traditional PE?

Yes. Games such as Dance Dance Revolution disguise real exercise as entertainment, inspiring even nonathletic kids to take an active role in their health.
16% (12 votes)
Maybe. Both approaches have their strengths and weaknesses, and schools should use them in conjunction with one another.
55% (41 votes)
No. A traditional PE workout, with an emphasis on healthy competition and teamwork, is still the best way to keep kids fit.
28% (21 votes)
None of the above. (Comment below.)
1% (1 vote)
Total votes: 75
0
was this helpful?
therese Duffy
Posted on 7/15/2008 6:38pm

Digital PE

If the traditional PE workout were working, we wouldn't have an abundance of obese students in our population. Digital is where todays students live, educators need to join the digital reality and change the way we teach in all areas including PE.

0
was this helpful?
Shane Roberts
Posted on 7/17/2008 1:51am

Obesity not due to ineffectiveness PE program

It is a narrow minded view to blame the presence of obesity on supposed ineffectiveness of current PE programs. What innovations like Dance Dance do is replace a teacher in front of the class leading the physical activity, they do not change activity levels. Is it a benefit to role model to students that adults aren't active by replacing them with animation? What changes activity levels (which are completely different to obesity) is the passion of the teacher and the commitment of the school. If it is not seen as important, it won't work.

0
was this helpful?
Nicole Frase
Posted on 7/17/2008 11:47am

Digital PE

It isn't the traditional PE classes that is resulting in an abundance of obese students, it is their lifestyle. The way we eat and our exercise level all, obviously, effect our health. Americans do not eat healthy, and unfortunately our youth are becoming less and less physically active. Perhaps adding a new, digital portion to PE would spice the classroom up a bit, however, I believe it to be a unfair and innacurate suggestion that traditional PE classes are the cause of rising obesity.

0
was this helpful?
Emily Grice, Eagle Harbor HS
Posted on 7/17/2008 12:08pm

Online physical education programs

Companies like Apex Virtual School offer an on-line PE that helps students set up a personal workout program, gives exercise instruction that doesn't require fancy equipment, and had interactive learning about related topics like healthy hearts, nutrition, and safety. Many students, like myself as a child, are intimidated by dodgeball but love jump rope. Having an individualized program builds self-esteem while establishing life-long exercise habits.

0
was this helpful?
Mary
Posted on 7/18/2008 1:19pm

Physical Educator

DDR is cost prohibitive, this is a great activity to put in the student center for access during lunch. Physical Education in the State of CA has a rich curriculum. I have just taken a summer fitness class in core strength and stability, I taught it as part of the fitness portion of my classes last year. Fitness is much more than cardio, what about strength and balance? Core fitness and stability is non stop, different every day and has strong appeal for the student who wants to get fit and not be bored. Furthermore, DDR is not an example of "technology in education" anymore than wearing an IPod while jogging is. Please.

0
was this helpful?
Nancy Carr
Posted on 7/23/2008 12:12pm

PE & Dance

Physical Education is a phenomena of United States schools and is a set of core expectations through eight component strands and three standards(at high school level) or five (elementary level) in California. Physical Education is not simply a focus on one thing, dance taught to physical education standards, a team sport or the like. It is a set of learning expectations at each grade level K-8 and a set of learning expectations for high school in our state. To do only "one thing" such as this program suggests is NOT physical education, it is an activity that is physical. The same is true of football, swimming, and the like - they are not physical education but a sport or athletics that is active. Physical Education prepares students for a healthy and fit life beyond school.

0
was this helpful?
OliviaB.
Posted on 3/18/2009 12:56pm

How about weight training geared towards kids

If we're talking about cardiovascular exercises, a digital supplement could help. But I've also seen kids learning how to use weights and muscle strengthening machines. Of course, they can't do as much as adults since they're still developing, but giving them a more systematic approach to toning themselves gives them knowledge on top of exercise.
--------
OliviaB.
Portland DUI lawyer

0
was this helpful?
anna
Posted on 5/26/2009 12:33pm

Digital fitness can work both ways

Digital fitness has the ability to provide kids with both very traditional and truly modern forms of physical activity. If you think about it actually, the Internet provides a means to absolutely anything.

Take GoTrybe.com for instance... this site provides digital fitness videos led by certified trainers that can be projected for a PE or traditional classroom and leads students through fitness workouts of all kinds. These workouts include hip hop dancing, kick boxing, strength and conditioning, cardio, salsa dancing, zumba, sport specific drills, and much more. Digital classrooms have the ability to provide virtually anything if it's used in the right way.

0
was this helpful?
weight training
Posted on 10/01/2009 12:55am

Hiiiiiiii

I realize the vexation which is been roseate. The things status to be sorted
out because it is near the various but it can be with everyone.

Sara
weight training

0
was this helpful?
Teacher
Posted on 11/17/2009 10:18pm

Excellent post thank you very much for taking the time to share with those who are starting on the subject. Greetings
burn the fat feed the muscle

Post a comment

Sign in or create an account now, or after you post.

Sign In

Thanks for your comment. It will be posted once you've signed in to your account. Please sign in here
Not yet a member of the Edutopia community? Create an Account

Create an Account

Almost there! As soon as your account is created, your new comment will be posted.
Mollom CAPTCHA (play audio CAPTCHA)
By creating an account, you agree to Edutopia's terms of use.