What Works in Public Education

Advertisement

The Edutopia Poll

by Sara Bernard

Print Forward Share Comments(30) Comment RSS

The “highly qualified” teacher requirements defined by the No Child Left Behind Act have, like so many parts of NCLB, come under serious scrutiny. Though some people say the current requirements prevent many qualified individuals from joining or staying in the profession, others contend that they don’t do much to ensure that all students have effective teachers.

One of the current proposals for NCLB revision, the All Students Can Achieve Act of 2007, suggests teacher quality should be measured by the educator’s effect on student achievement, rather than by credentials alone. If you had to rewrite NCLB’s requirements for teacher quality, what would you include? Tell us what you think.

What makes a highly qualified teacher?

Degree, certification, and demonstrated mastery of one’s subject(s) (the current system under NCLB)
12% (19 votes)
Proven results based on student performance
5% (8 votes)
All of the above plus individualized and continual professional development and evaluation
52% (83 votes)
Basic credentials, but beyond that, teacher effectiveness should be measured locally and case by case
28% (45 votes)
None of the above (comment below)
4% (6 votes)
Total votes: 161
0
was this helpful?
Anonymous
Posted on 8/01/2007 5:45pm

BA and MS in subject area of teaching, particularly Science and Math. Current state Certification is almost meaningless, because a BA in Education is mostly preferable in most states to a BA or BS in Science or Math, Certifcation laws need to be changed to give automatic certification to people with MA or MS degress in the subject area of teaching.

0
was this helpful?
Tracy Taylor
Posted on 8/01/2007 5:58pm

What makes a highly qualified teacher?

Ability to differentiate curricula and assessments for individual children. To motivate children to want to continue learning. To Inspire!

0
was this helpful?
Marcia
Posted on 8/01/2007 6:33pm

Highly Qualified

I believe that a highly qualified teacher is measured by performance in the classroom, continual professional development, experience, and evaluation by peers and students. Does one need more than a bachelor's degree? I don't think so. Just a willingness to continue learning and growing along with changes in curriculum and methodology.

0
was this helpful?
roy
Posted on 8/01/2007 7:23pm

the student

One must reach the student and bring out the best in him. So that he or she retain the information and makes a personal connection with the materail.

0
was this helpful?
Gordon
Posted on 8/02/2007 4:20am

Highly Qualified

You can have all the degrees and not be qualified to teach any subject. Possessing knowledge of the curriculum content means little if you no not possess; the skill with which to present the material, the ability to relate to the students, and lack the desire to impart this knowledge to children. If we cannot reach the children by loving them, they will not open up to what you can teach them. Qualifications to teach should include some way to determine their desire and empathy toward children. We have to care first.

0
was this helpful?
Rick Shepker
Posted on 8/02/2007 5:00am

Great teachers

Teacher education does not make a highly qualified teacher. A highly qualified teacher is one who loves their job, is able to make their subject matter exciting and learn-able to their students and is willing to take the risks necessary for students to learn. We are caught in the world of standardized tests that prove only that we can teach the test to a large number of students and make our numbers look good.

0
was this helpful?
Sharon Bodley
Posted on 8/02/2007 6:01am

What makes a good teacher

We don't need just "good" teachers - we need great ones. Ones that can connect with students, recognize the teachable monemt, have knowledge of their subjects, and are flexible to adapt and use new ideas and methods.
Without all of the above, no degree - no matter how high when earned can make a highly qualified teacher.

0
was this helpful?
Anonymous
Posted on 8/02/2007 6:16am

Highly qualified teachers are those teachers who light the spark for students to want to learn. All the credentials in the world will not help a child learn if the child is not motivated. A highly qualified teacher also recognizes the learning style and level at which a student is able to learn. The HQ teacher then uses the knowledge to effectively motivate the student.

0
was this helpful?
RogerM
Posted on 8/02/2007 12:16pm

Highly Qualified Teachers

The best way to determine whether a teacher is "highly qualified", or any other level of qualification is to ask their students, their principal or their peers.

We don't measure student success, so you can't use that. Degrees do not tell you anything about whether they can teach or not. Continuing ed, ditto. You can't measure a person's performance by these static means.

Let the building personnel determine qualifications based on performance in the classroom, staffroom and hallways.

0
was this helpful?
Leonard Isenberg
Posted on 8/02/2007 5:41pm

Highly Qualified Teacher

My mother was a highly qualified teacher who taught for 30 years on a lifetime credential that required no further units. Although she was under no obligation to continue taking classes or submit herself to vacuous staff development that I have never seen implemented, she always took classes and sought other avenues of learning throughout her life. She was part of an innercity Los Angeles Unified School District that at the time was a self-motivated professional teaching corp that demanded and achieved excellence from its students.

Degrees, certification, and demonstrated mastery are of no avail in the present LAUSD - even to a "highly qualified teacher" - if the students the teacher is given continue to be socially promoted and are years behind in the mastery of grade-level standards.

As a high school teacher, I have no trouble having my competency as a teacher judged by student performance, if the initial level of my students is taken into consideration in making this assessment. However, asking me to achieve grade-level standards for students who enter my classroom years behind after being socially promoted is dishonesty.

Trying to shift the focus of the present failed public education system to teachers by seeking "highly qualified teachers" is less than forthright when garden variety qualified teachers like my mother would do just fine if someone had the political guts to draw the line in terms of minimal grade-level achievement necessary for passage on a grade by grade basis. Or to paraphrase former President Harry Truman, "The buck stops where?"

Post a comment

Sign in or create an account now, or after you post.

Sign In

Thanks for your comment. It will be posted once you've signed in to your account. Please sign in here
Not yet a member of the Edutopia community? Create an Account

Create an Account

Almost there! As soon as your account is created, your new comment will be posted.
Mollom CAPTCHA (play audio CAPTCHA)
By creating an account, you agree to Edutopia's terms of use.