Why don't US elementary schools teach foreign language? | Edutopia
Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation

Why don't US elementary schools teach foreign language?

Why don't US elementary schools teach foreign language?

Related Tags: World Languages
More Related Discussions
13 7274 Views

I am currently enrolled in a graduate program, which will certify me as a literacy specialist. We have studied many trends and issues in literacy education. One of the topics we have discussed is whether U.S. elementary schools(K-6)should be teaching foreign language in the curriculum. We are a global society today and the world wide web is connecting us in multiple pathways. We need to become more culturally aware of other students especially with the growing rate of ELL students in U.S. schools today. Researchers have also proven that learning a foreign language helps to develop cognitive skills that improve reading and even math scores. Does your school teach foreign language in elementary school? How is this improving their learning? If not, do you think foreign language should be taught in elementary school? How might we fit foreign language into the curriculum? I would appreciate any comments or suggestions. Thank you.


This post was created by a member of Edutopia's community. If you have your own #eduawesome tips, strategies, and ideas for improving education, share them with us.

Print
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Share

Comments (13)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Don Doehla, MA, NBCT's picture
Don Doehla, MA, NBCT
2015 California Language Teacher of the Year, Co-Director Berkeley WL Project at UC Berkeley Language Center

Thanks for your post Hans. Other countries are doing some interesting second language programs, some successfully, some less so.

Does anyone else have an example to share? How can we successfully promote language programs in the early years of school in all countries? The need is great! Let's think of some ideas together!!

Best wishes, Don

tom n's picture
tom n
Elementary Spanish

It seems as if money is precisely why my district offers elementary Spanish. Oakland County, Michigan, where I work, is one of the wealthiest counties in the country. In order to differentiate ourselves from neighboring districts that only offer 3-5th grade Spanish, we offer K-5 Spanish. A lot of charter schools also teach WL and that ups the ante too.
Most parents in my area expect WL instruction. Spanish is by far the language of choice as the handwriting is on the wall as to Latino population growth.
Birmingham, Bloomfield Hills, Clarkston( Mandarin too), Royal Oak. Ferndale and Southfield are all communities with many years of elementary Spanish instruction.
Hasta Luego,

Tom Noes

tom n's picture
tom n
Elementary Spanish

It seems as if money is precisely why my district offers elementary Spanish. Oakland County, Michigan, where I work, is one of the wealthiest counties in the country. In order to differentiate ourselves from neighboring districts that only offer 3-5th grade Spanish, we offer K-5 Spanish. A lot of charter schools also teach WL and that ups the ante too.
Most parents in my area expect WL instruction. Spanish is by far the language of choice as the handwriting is on the wall as to Latino population growth.
Birmingham, Bloomfield Hills, Clarkston( Mandarin too), Royal Oak. Ferndale and Southfield are all communities with many years of elementary Spanish instruction.
Hasta Luego,

Tom Noes

vanenka mosqueira's picture
vanenka mosqueira
Spanish teacher/ Spanish Language Coordinator

How do you know the needs of your students with regard to their language background? In America if we focus on our student diverse population, we should integrate in our teaching practices awareness of different language heritage. It is a challenging situation of working to improve our students educational progress when we neglect or not value their cultural diversity. Perhaps we can discuss of ways in which you feel that your students' mother tongue language may have been neglected?
Thanks,
Vanenka

maski99's picture

I am in elementary school as a 5th grader and I've been wanting to learn Japanese in elementary school. (I am a Japanese-American) Can you please tell the elementary schools of America to allow foreign language classes in elementary schools other than English as a second language? PLEASE? PLEASE??????????????

(1)
maski99's picture

I think you are right Don. There are too many people in America that only speak on language. At least there are some people who speak more than one language. I speak a little bit of nihongo and I am only a 5th grader! (nihongo means Japanese, by the way) The American states and government need to stop worrying about money for themselves. >:-(

(1)
Samer Rabadi's picture
Samer Rabadi
Online Community Manager

Hi maski99, welcome to Edutopia. :-)

There are huge benefits to students learning more than one language. Even if your school doesn't offer formal classes, there are other ways to learn--both at home and through organizations or clubs. You should go for it!

Ganbatte!

Don Doehla, MA, NBCT's picture
Don Doehla, MA, NBCT
2015 California Language Teacher of the Year, Co-Director Berkeley WL Project at UC Berkeley Language Center

To @Maski99-san,

doumoarigatougozaimasu
Doumo arigatou gozaimasu
Thank you very much !

I am not only impressed that you are learning some Japanese, but that as a 5th grader, you are also reading articles on Edutopia! Well done, and keep making the world a better place by working at becoming bi-lingual, and bi-literate, if not multi-lingual, and multi-literate! I admire your comments as well. Thanks for posting!

Don

florentina's picture

Hi everyone. I am a French teacher in Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, a small community close to Savannah, GA. My daughters are in 2nd and 5th grade and they do learn Spanish in school, 50% immersion program. Our community is wealthier than others in the area, but we are also an IB high school ( International Bacalaureate). I truly believe that ALL schools in America, especially in Elementary schools should offer at least two languages to begin exploring from early ages. I am currently speaking 4 languages (Romanian, English, French and Spanish) because in my country of origin (Romania) learning language was an expectation. The younger you are, the faster you learn a new language
My students coming from middle school with little or no language skill face challenges and often give up on learning. We have an IB program in which by fourth year of language study, the students have to prove fluency and to write extended essays, graded in other countries. How do you think they perform when they compete with European students who learn languages from pre-K?

Many times I had an opinion that language learning facilitates mathematical skills and communication skills in the native language. But now, I know it is not an opinion, but a proven fact. The article from July, 2014 in Times magazine lists and describes the many benefits of a bilingual brain.
I believe that in our century, with a real technology revolution, we can come together and advocate for language learning as a norm, not a graduation requirement.

Thank you for reading!

Florentina Hartley

Fox Lehjika's picture
Fox Lehjika
World Language

At Oxford Preparatory Academy we offer Mandarin, Italian, German, and French in a K-8 program. From pre-K to 4th grades student learn Mandarin, which is a category 4 in difficulty. From 5th grade students choose a target language they study up to 8th grade. We use the multiple intelligences technique to create a learning setting based on the California World Language Standards. When it comes to world language we believe that starting earlier and staying longer is the best strategy for students to reach an acceptable proficiency level. All of this is made possible thanks to the school leadership that understands the need for students to develop the 21st century skills necessary to compete in today's global market environment. Such global minded leadership is what is needed in our elementary and secondary school. (See my previous post for more details).

maski99's picture

I think you are right Don. There are too many people in America that only speak on language. At least there are some people who speak more than one language. I speak a little bit of nihongo and I am only a 5th grader! (nihongo means Japanese, by the way) The American states and government need to stop worrying about money for themselves. >:-(

(1)
maski99's picture

I am in elementary school as a 5th grader and I've been wanting to learn Japanese in elementary school. (I am a Japanese-American) Can you please tell the elementary schools of America to allow foreign language classes in elementary schools other than English as a second language? PLEASE? PLEASE??????????????

(1)

Sign in to comment. Not a member? Register.