STEM education provides many opportunities and challenges. How can our practice evolve to meet the needs of 21st-century learners?

A Common Core Standard: "Critique the reasoning of others"

Lucas Cioffi Civic Entrepreneur in Charlottesville, VA

I was reading about the NYC gap apps challenge which is aims to build skills in the 8 Common Core Standards for Mathematical Practice:
*Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them
*Reason abstractly and quantitatively
*Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others
*Model with mathematics
*Use appropriate tools strategically
*Attend to precision
*Look for and make use of structure
*Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning

Has anyone effectively found a way to have students "critique the reasoning of others" or is this something that's in the common core but not used in practice?

Comments (7)

Comment RSS

I think the debate on Common

Was this helpful?
+1

I think the debate on Common Core School Standards between Politicians and Politicians, Politicians and Educators, Educators and Educators etc., keeps going on. However, everyone forgets to include the most important factor in the equation: Parents and Students. The adoption of the standards are going to impact students and parents the most, yet the recent findings of a Gallup poll showed a majority of US parents do not understand what Common Core School Standards are all about.

I believe, if the forum is

Was this helpful?
+1

I believe, if the forum is about students
why not include parents, and students.

It seems to me education has

Was this helpful?
0

It seems to me education has become, more political
than being about the education of our children.

One way to get students

Was this helpful?
0

One way to get students started "critiquing the reasoning of others" is to give students two scenarios, for example "juan thinks ... because; juanita disagrees, she thinks .... because" and then have students decide who they agree with and why, as well as identify what is wrong in the other student's reasoning. It works especially well when you identify a common misconception that students have, but one that is within their capacity to reason about.

Producer LD Podcast, Digital Media Consultant, Author

While I think the media is

Was this helpful?
+1

While I think the media is doing a generally horrible job at explaining common core, once I explain it to parents, they are generally receptive. And overall, I think we should never really cut students or parents out of these discussions. Education is not a widget you can pick up off the shelf, it's an ongoing process, and if teachers need and want support, they also need to make at least a small effort to make sure parents have an opportunity to know what's going on in the classroom, along with a few ideas to support and expand learning on the home front. After all, at least a portion of parents would love to help their children do better in school- why not look at that as having a "student" or "adjunct" teacher for the kids at home, and give them a few assignments every once in a while as well?

Producer LD Podcast, Digital Media Consultant, Author

As to helping out with

Was this helpful?
+1

As to helping out with critiquing the reasoning of others- this can happen within a typical classroom discussion, especially when there are opportunities for more than one "right" answer. Instead of saying a simple "That's right!" try calling on another student and asking "What do you think of what Opal said? " As long as things are respectful, you get to hear divergent views while teaching kids to critique each other without being disagreeable- a skill we all need to learn :)

PBLmakes the student think

Was this helpful?
0

PBLmakes the student think and support th sulution to the challenge or question..Using multimedia to clarify and illustrate te min points. It teaches students how to solve problems and become a successful manager as well as developing other skills.

see more see less