Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

K-5 iPad Apps for Understanding (Bloom's Revised Taxonomy, Part 2)

Benjamin Bloom's second stage, "understanding" occurs when new learning connects to prior knowledge. At this point, students have the ability to make sense of what they have read, viewed, or heard and can explain this understanding clearly and succinctly to others. This particular learning stage balances precariously between communicating understanding and expressing opinion. Here the student demonstrates the ability to identify the main idea, generalize new material, translate verbal content into a visual form, transform abstract concepts into everyday terms, or make predictions.

Writing and speaking are the most common way teachers "check for understanding," but mobile technology is helping to break this traditional mold. With the wealth of media creation apps available, rich opportunities for students to express understanding are literally at our fingertips. Classroom teachers can carefully curate an app environment on a mobile device that differentiates the learning process and honors the students' ability to make choices. Multi-media presentations can highlight students' ability to summarize and explain key ideas. Using video and audio apps is also an effective way to document learning. These media files act as a concrete demonstration of understanding to include in digital portfolios, blogs, or wikis. Together these media files serve as an alternative form of assessment far move revealing than the often-used standardized bubble test.

Understanding

Apps that fit into this "understanding" stage provide opportunities for students to explain ideas or concepts. Verbs commonly used to describe this phase include interpreting; restating, retelling, summarizing, inferring, generalizing, comparing, rephrasing, translating, reporting, clarifying, and paraphrasing. Understanding apps step away from the selection of a "right" answer and introduce a more open-ended format for students to summarize content and translate meaning.

Criteria

When locating these understanding apps, consider the following questions. Does the app help the user . . .

  • Summarize facts and ideas?
  • Restate methods or procedures?
  • Interpret relationships?
  • Paraphrase information?
  • Predict consequences?
  • Give examples?
  • Retell information in own words?
  • Retell events?
  • State problem in own words?
  • Explain ideas or concepts?
  • Determine importance?

Additionally take time to consider the following element:

  • Does the app employ playful interactive formats that captivate the user's attention? Making learning "fun" is a very valuable component and if the app is also cognitively demanding, it can help learning "stick."

The Reviews

photostory HD
The original purpose of Photostory was to develop babies' receptive and oral language skills. However, possibly it also holds promise as an app for second language students. In many ways, this is a traditional "remembering" app. The child selects the right answer by tapping the picture, but the simple integration of a story recording function notches the higher-level thinking up a bit. The voice recording option provides an opportunity for students to paraphrase what they are learning in their own words. The teacher can also personalize the learning experience by uploading photographs of classroom-shared learning experiences, creating hot spots for students to select, and developing unique questions for each child to answer. Since the teacher is in control of the exact phrasing of each question, it is easy to target understanding skills directly. For example, instead of asking students to find a certain object, ask them to pick an object that is the best answer out of several suitable choices. This app's ingenious integration of voice recording is a great way to offer students a chance to articulate personal understanding. The embedding audio/video recording or a response journal within a learning app is a promising feature.

Lifecards - Postcards
Translating the meaning of a graphic into writing and vice versa is another example of "understanding." With the Lifecards app, students can import a graph, chart, historic photograph, symbols, diagram, or even political cartoons onto one side of a postcard and then use a letter-writing format to explain the graphic on the other side. The limited space for writing will demand that communication immediately address the content's main idea and force students to determine what information is the most significant. Teachers can also choose to provide the writing instead and ask students to create a visual representation of the letter's contents. Students can use photographs taken with a mobile device or graphics saved in the iPhoto library. I am sure the creators of Lifecards had different intentions for their app but their beautifully designed, one-ended app proves to have many possible uses.

iLiveMath
The iLiveMath apps present word problems that are full of rich vocabulary and gorgeous photographs. Each app contains three levels of difficulty and includes basic questions directed at adding, subtracting, dividing, and multiplying. They each also address a separate subset of skills such as speed, distance, time, fractions, counting, geometry, money, mean, median, mode, and range. Instead of selecting an answer from a multiple-choice line-up, iLiveMath employs the use of a number wheel that has the potential of holding 12 or more possible answers. At the end of a session, it is possible to review performance results and email them. The themes of each app connect to other subject areas such as science, history, or technology. Each app's unique subject matter comes with supportive links to educational sites and short video clips. This is a rich series of educational apps that will assist a child's understanding of how to solve a word problem and connect to subjects found in the real world, and will also spark curiosity.

ShowMe Interactive Whiteboard
ShowMe is an interactive whiteboard that can record a screencast on the iPad. It will import photos or graphics from iPhoto, has simple drawing tools, an eraser, and voice recording. Having a tool that incorporates graphics with voice recordings provides a wonderful opportunity for students to translate material they have read. Consider asking students to narrate a map of a character's journey, create a timeline, sketch diagrams, animate a recording of the water cycle, or explain the results from a class poll. Teachers will need to create an account in order for users to save work to showme.com. Uploading content to this site will provide an embed code, and enable the ability to email the file or post it to Twitter or Facebook.

Motion Math HD
Learn fractions and decimals while tilting and turning the iPad. This app definitely wins the Fun Factor Award! Perfect for the kinesthetic and visual learner, Motion Math intermingles a variety of ways to recognize fractions. The graphic representations of the fractions alternate between numerator over denominator, pie charts, decimals, and percents. The goal of the game is to identify the correct answer by bouncing a flaming star at the correct point on a number line. Users need to constantly correlate a wide selection of fractions to a continually varying sequence of numbers. The diverse representation of fractions is a great way for children to make connections between separate areas of prior knowledge. With its constant translation of one symbolic form of a fraction to another, this app is prompting users to develop a deeper understanding of fractions. The app also responds to user performance and will automatically increase or decrease the level of difficulty.

Strip Designer
Ask students to retell the sequence of events in a Revolutionary War battle, folktale, science experiment, or the states of matter in the context of a graphic novel. Strip Designer can import maps, images from iPhoto, or photographs taken with a mobile device directly into a comic strip template. There is a wonderful selection of fonts, colors, text balloons, stickers, paper backgrounds, frames, and filters from which to pick. Students will need to choose a page template that best matches the number of events they plan to retell. With all these wonderful graphic features, it will be a challenge for students to explain events succinctly while sticking to the facts. When the graphic novels are complete, simply save the comics to iPhoto, print them out, or email as a JPEG, PNG, or PDF file. The app will also connect to Facebook, Flickr, or Twitpic. Retelling events in comic strip format is definitely a great way to build understanding skills and spice up a traditional paper and pencil report.

Question Builder for the iPad
Mobile Education Tools make a wonderful series of apps meant to help elementary age children with special needs develop language skills. Question builder targets a child's ability to use inference to answer an abstract question. The questions come in five formats (what, how, why, where, and random) and function at three different levels of difficulty. Many users can share accounts within the same app and still receive a complete summary report. These reports detail performance in each question category and level. This app models how Bloom imagined inference operating at the "understanding" level. Question Builder is asking young children to carefully consider the explicit information given in an illustration and then predict the intended meaning. Every elementary student will benefit from developing this thinking skill.

Bluster!
Bluster helps students develop vocabulary skills while learning to recognize word patterns. In order to answer a question, students need to select three words from a list that share a common relationship. For example: locate three rhyming words, words with common prefixes or suffixes, synonyms, homophones, adjectives, or word roots. The passing parade of words becomes shorter each time a student selects a new trio. Adjust the Bluster settings to meet the instructional needs of students between second and fourth grade. Students can play the game alone, as a team member, or choose to take on a head to head competition.

Confer
The most informative assessment occurs when teachers have an opportunity to conference individually with a student. These are the precious moments when a teacher can listen attentively to a child explain how to do a math problem, engage in discussions with her about her writing, or hear her predictions about a book's outcome. Classroom teachers are constantly asking students to articulate what they are learning. The Confer app is useful for teacher documentation of these conversations. The mobility of this technology makes it easy to jot down quick, yet informative notes about an individual or small group of students. For example, teachers are able to list student learning strengths, enter a reading level, keep track of conference dates, and plan for the next teaching point. It is possible to export or import records through email and sort files by conference dates, groups, or tags. With a gmail account, data can upload as a spreadsheet. The juggling of a teacher's busy day just got a little bit easier.

Go to Part Three of Bloom's Revised Taxonomy: Applying.

Comments (5)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Jeanne Reed's picture
Jeanne Reed
Computer Specialist for Manhattan Beach K-5 school

Thanks these reviews are super helpful!

Sharon Vogt's picture

I believe that one of the ways technology can be used to improve education is as a means of giving students more opportunities to communicate -- to share their thinking and understanding with others. So I appreciate you addressing this issue in connection with iPad Apps.

Most of the Apps you included do help students verbalize their understanding or help teachers document it, except for the two math apps and Bluster. These apps only test knowledge. Then don't let students do any of the things you recommended in your criteria.

The iLiveMath app has the appearance of connecting math to the real world when it really only connects math to colorful pictures. Most of the problems in the app aren't problems you would solve in the real world (Does a whale really "sing" for 24 hours straight?) And, did you notice how often the same problem comes up with different numbers? In a demo of level 3 I viewed, every 4th problem was a repeat, just different numbers. So this app assesses only a narrow range of math skills. It's attractive photos are what sells it, and that is its best feature.

Diane Darrow's picture
Diane Darrow
Artist and Educator
Blogger 2014

Here is my little secret, some of the math apps were originally slated for remembering but I asked for them to be pulled at the last minute. Here was my reasoning ...
Under "understanding" or really "comprehension" Bloom speaks about the transfer of one form of knowledge to another form as a way to build comprehension. Thus a verbal word problem becomes sentence of symbols and numbers, a fraction becomes a decimal and a percentage a point on a number line. These changes are slight yet significant. Asking students to translate between different forms of content is not the same as finding the right answer from a multiple choice line up, so these apps got a boost up. I also need to add that the revised taxonomy has levels within each cognitive domain which can blur the lines even more. Thank you for your comments, I appreciate the dialog.

Helen Gounaris's picture
Helen Gounaris
8th grade special education math teacher

Hi - Can you recommend some math ipad apps for the special education middle school child? (Grades 6-8). Thank you

Christine Awbrey's picture
Christine Awbrey
4th grade STEM teacher from Richfield, Minnesota

Thanks for sharing your ideas on checking for understanding using apps. I agree that you would get more feedback from using one of these apps than from a bubble multiple choice test. Many of the apps you describe sound very engaging for the students to write and speak about what they know. It really gives options for creative assessment.

Discussion A Code of Conduct for Presenters

Last comment 7 hours 44 min ago in Professional Development

Discussion Toss the Script

Last comment 1 day 3 hours ago in Lesson Plans

Discussion Top 11 things to consider when choosing a higher education software

Last comment 4 days 11 hours ago in Technology Integration

Discussion Taking the Plunge with Social Media in the Classroom

Last comment 2 days 10 hours ago in Technology Integration

Discussion NaNoWriMo: An #EduAwesome Project for Your #BestYearEver

Last comment 5 days 4 hours ago in Project-Based Learning

Sign in and Join the Discussion! Not a member? Register to join the discussion.