Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

Using Photos With English-Language Learners

Larry Ferlazzo

I teach English & Social Studies at inner-city high school in Sacramento,CA
"A picture is worth a thousand words."
-- Unknown

Though the origin of this popular adage is unclear, one thing is clear: using photos with English-Language Learners (ELLs) can be enormously effective in helping them learn far more than a thousand words -- and how to use them.

Usable images for lessons can be found online or teachers and students can take and use their own.

The activities presented below connect to multiple Common Core Standards including the following ELA Standards:

  • Integrate and evaluate information presented in diverse media and formats, including visually, quantitatively, and orally.
  • Develop the topic with relevant, well-chosen facts, definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples.
  • Use precise language and domain-specific vocabulary to inform about or explain the topic.

Picture Word Inductive Model

The Picture Word Inductive Model (PWIM) is one of our favorites. In it, students first brainstorm twenty words related to a picture, then put those words into categories and add new ones that fit those categories. Next they complete a "cloze" (or fill-in-the-blank) activity with sentences about the picture which they then put into categories of their own. They convert those sentence categories into paragraphs, and, finally, arrange the paragraphs into essays. Lastly, a title is chosen.

The PWIM uses an inductive process (in which students seek patterns and use them to identify their broader meanings and significance), as opposed to a deductive process (where meanings or rules are given, and students have to then apply them). It takes advantage of student prior knowledge and visual clues and builds on the key strength of inductive learning—the brain's natural desire to seek out and remember patterns.

Research has shown that it is an effective way for students to learn to develop vocabulary and to read. You can find a more detailed description and timeline on how we use it in this transcript of a recent podcast I produced.

The best pictures to use in this activity contain one scene with many different objects. A recent study has found that the most memorable photos have a little "strangeness" about them, and include people and a sense of movement. Those attributes might be helpful to keep in mind when choosing a photo.

For example, this New York Times photo fits most of those criteria and could be used when teaching the themes of family or food.

Students can choose and label pictures online using this strategy with many newly unveiled online tools like Thinglink and Szoter. You can see examples of annotated photos using both of these free site here.

Thought Bubbles

Students can create "thought bubbles" for characters in photos. What might the people in this picture be thinking, or what about this dog? Bubblr and ImgOps are super-easy tools for students to create these kinds of "bubbles" with online photos.

Picture Dictation

In picture dictation, the teacher can pick an image and, without showing it to the class, describe it while students draw. It can also be a partner activity where half of the class is given one picture and the other half a different one. Students with different pictures are made partners and stand up a book or folder between them. One student describes her picture while the other draws. When it's complete and the student is given feedback, the roles can be reversed. Students can also be asked to write sentences describing the picture.

Bloom's Taxonomy

For more advanced English-Language Learners, using photos can be a good way to help them learn about Bloom's Taxonomy. In an exercise borrowed from Learn North Carolina, following an introduction to the different levels of Bloom's, students can apply their new knowledge towards developing leveled questions about a photo.

For example, a teacher could use this photo and model asking questions for each category:

  • Knowledge: What items or people can you name with the vocabulary you know?
  • Comprehension: What is happening in the photo?
  • Application: What one sentence caption would you write?
  • Analysis: Where do you think they are?
  • Synthesis: What might they be thinking?
  • Evaluation: Are they too young to play soccer? Why or why not?

The teacher could have one or more other photos to distribute, along with a sheet of "question starters" (you can find several here) categorized by the Bloom's level to help scaffold the activity. Students could work in partners to develop their own sequence of questions to share.

Compare and Contrast

Students can identify the similarities and differences between two different images. This can lead to practice with the academic vocabulary needed when making comparisons. For example, students could view two different images such as two photos from this slideshow, which features pictures of expectant parents standing in their babies' nurseries and "empty nesters" standing in their children's old rooms. They could use a Venn Diagram to record similarities and differences. After sharing with a partner and as a class, students could generate sentences and even paragraphs about the images. For beginning students, the teacher could supply sentence frames such as:

  • "Both pictures have _________."
  • "One difference is _____________."
  • "In the first picture there is ____________, but in the second picture there is ___________."

You can see two more example photos and read more about how to use this strategy here.

Image Detective

Image Detective is an online media literacy activity which could be adapted to use with any photo -- these, for example. First, the teacher or student poses a question about the photo. Next, the student identifies clues in the photo that help them answer the question. Then, the student investigates background information on the picture and/or topic it represents. Finally, the student makes his/her conclusion. The final project looks like this:

  • My Question Is:
  • Clues I've Identified:
  • I am fairly confident that:
  • My best reasons for thinking this are:
  • A question this raised for me is:

Using Images to Generate Writing

Using images to prompt writing is a key strategy we use with our English-Language Learners. Pictures are immediately engaging and often less daunting for students than texts. We often use images to push language development and thinking skills within a thematic unit. For example, we ask students to look at an image posted on the wall, on a document camera, or overhead. We've used the following image of apartheid in South Africa during a unit on Nelson Mandela.

First, students describe in writing what they observe, trying to record as many details as possible. It helps if students have a copy of the image on which they can write. Then the teacher asks students to write as many questions they can think of about the image and the details they have listed. Once students have shared their questions with a classmate, the teacher asks them to use the inductive process (described above in the Picture Word Inductive Model) to organize these questions into categories (for example, questions about feelings/emotions or historical questions) and then to add more questions to each category. These questions could serve as writing entry points for students to develop longer writing pieces based on the image.

Research has shown that these types of inquiry activities—where students are asked to analyze a piece of concrete data such as a picture or an object in order to generate ideas for writing—are an effective instructional practice for improving the writing of adolescent learners.

Five Card Flickr Story is another photo tool for generating writing. It lets you pick five photos from a group of pre-selected images from Flickr and then write a story about them. It saves your selection and story, and provides you with a link to it. No registration is required.

Another tool, Pic-Lits, lets users pick an image from a selection and then "drag-and-drop" words onto the image. The user's creation can then be saved with a link posted, or it can be embedded. The words you can choose from are labeled by their parts of speech, and once you drop the word on the image you can see all the different verb conjugations and choose one. You can write a poem or describe the picture. You also have the option of writing whatever words you want if you don't want to be limited by the words available to drag-and-drop.

Using Images For Speaking Practice

Fotobabble is the most simple photo and audio recording tool we've found for online speaking practice. Students can choose a photo and record their description of it with Fotobabble. Students can listen to their recording at the beginning of the year, and then record it again later to see the progress that they have made. It can also be posted on a class or student blog, and others can leave comments.

We look forward to hearing the ways you use images with your students!

Larry Ferlazzo and Katie Hull Sypnieski are teachers at Luther Burbank High School in Sacramento, California. Portions of this column are excerpts from their new book, The ESL/ELL Teacher's Survival Guide: Ready-to-Use Strategies, Tools, and Activities for Teaching English-Language Learners of All Levels. Larry also writes a popular blog for educators and a teacher advice column for Education Week Teacher.

Engaging English Language Learners with Photos and Video

Comments (12)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Debbie's picture
Debbie
third grade general education teacher from Georgia

I love the idea of PWIM. I have a very diverse classroom this year. The majority of my students are gifted learners and I have five English Language Learners. I am struggling with ways to assess their understanding of the content that I teach them, especially in Science and Social Studies. I have been looking for ways that my English Language Learners can showcase their understanding with the knowledge they have. I will most definitely use this method within my classroom. In fact, I love all of these ideas. Thank you so much for providing such great detail on how to use appropiately. These are great!

Amanda's picture

You have great ideas. I have always struggled in the classroom with teaching ELL students. There is a paraprofessional at our school who works with ELL students in every classroom but there are so many students, she is pulled in 100 different directions. When she leaves the classroom, I often feel like ok now wht do I do? I usually show pictures to all of my students (ELL or not) when teaching vocabulary words. I really liked 2 of your ideas (Thought Bubbles and Picture Dictation). I am excited to use these in my classroom with my students. Thanks for sharing!

KGordon's picture

Thank you for all of the tips for working with ESL students! I am a General Education Science teacher who is teaching a 7th grade, very low level pull-out resource room for the very first time. Not only do I have three or four students that are barely reading on a second grade level, but I also have two ESL students in my room who are very intelligent but have been placed in my resource room because of their language barriers. I am not Special Ed certified nor ESL certified so the strategies that you mentioned are extremely helpful! I especially liked the thought bubbles idea (I'm thinking using it as an activity to show relationships among different organisms) and the image detective. I was going to ask if any of these programs have iPad friendly Apps because my school does have sets of Ipads available for the resource classrooms. Also, thank you Monica for providing me with the Perfect Captions app, I am definitely going to look into it!!

Monica Burns's picture
Monica Burns
Educator, Consultant, ADE , ClassTechTips.com
Blogger 2014

KGordon, so glad that you like the Perfect Captions app - I've used it in lots of different subject areas with my students. Check out my lesson plan using this app: http://bit.ly/T3iPM2 and more posts on my favorite apps at my blog: www.ClassTechTips.com

Renee Peters's picture

I did not know about fotobabble thank you for the tip. I have and still do work with ELL students, and I know it can be difficult at times. SIOP strategies work well when working with ELLs. Use as much visuals and hands on with your objectives the more the better! Have students retell when you are able to make sure they understood your expectations. Watch their body language sometimes you can tell they really did not get your message, just readdress a different way. My passion is working with ELLs, because I have walked in their shoes and totally understand where they are coming from - I say do want every you can think of to help them get the concept. Sometimes being animated helps too!

J.Oliver's picture

I am currently using picture prompts in my classroom for simple sentence writing assignments. The prompts also work well to encourage students to extend their descriptive language. One of the many ideas I will be using is the compare and contrast photo activity. I think this will allow my students to develop more confidence with their English language skills and simple observation. The Fotobabble program is something that I would like to use in my classroom to integrate more ICT activities for my ELL students. Your Ideas and best website list for ELL's have been very helpful. I cannot wait to share them with my colleagues.

Ellen Z.'s picture
Ellen Z.
Reading Specialist from Hellertown, PA

Pictures are a great way to get your students involved and are also very helpful with visual learners. There is a terrific website for those in the elementary grades which inspires creative writing called Cubert's Cube. Cubert's cube has a gallery feature where the student can upload a picture to write about. The gallery feature also gives the student the ability to draw his/her own picture as a story starter or illustration.

Austin's picture
Austin
CA credential student

Hi, I am currently in my

Hi, I am currently in my first year as a credential student at CSUN and I have been enlightened to so many new ways to incorporate interactive learning in the classroom through educational websites. What a useful tool in teaching visual learners, especially in early language development. Thanks for the tip for the useful website. I will be sure to keep Cubert's Cube in mind when I become an elementary school teacher. If you know of any other good learning sites please let me know. Thanks.

Deborah Ward's picture

A fellow colleague just share the Edutopia site with several of us. What a great find! What a wealth of images and information to help students expand their thinking and knowledge beyond the classroom. There are loads of great resources-thanks!

Holly W.'s picture
Holly W.
Curriculum and Instruction with a Specialization in ESL Student

I definitely agree that visuals are very effective in helping English language learners gain proficiency. The activities listed are all great ideas to use with ELLs! Most importantly, they all connect to the Common Core Standards. The activities mentioned that I especially like include: Thought Bubbles, Picture Dictation, Image Detective, and Using Images for Speaking Practice. With Thought Bubbles, students are using their critical thinking skills to come up with thoughts that characters may be having, all based on a picture. With Picture Dictation, students are given an opportunity to visualize what a picture looks like based solely on the description given to them. This activity allows students to use their artistic abilities through drawing while interacting with partners. I love the investigative nature of the Image Detective activity. I think ELLs would really enjoy identifying clues to help them answer the question posed to them, as well as investigating background information on the picture and/or topic it represents. The Image Detective activity would be great to use for science related topics because students can take on the role of scientists investigating real-world problems in an authentic learning environment. I like the Using Images for Speaking Practice activity because it allows students to see how much progress they have made on their speaking skills from the beginning of the school year until the end of the school year. The Picture Word Inductive Model (PWIM) also sounds like a great research-based activity to use with ELL students. I am most interested in using strategies that can help my ELLs develop vocabulary and improve their reading, writing, listening, and speaking skills.

Of the activities mentioned, I use Bloom's Taxonomy, Compare and Contrast, and I Use Images to Generate Writing with my students in my classroom. It is amazing how many activities can be used with photos. One activity that I find useful with younger elementary students is giving ELLs stickers related to the topic they are writing about. For instance, if students are writing a story about how they spent Easter/spring break with their families then the teacher can provide the students with colorful Easter/spring stickers (which may include images of bunnies, eggs, baskets, etc.). In this activity ELLs can replace words with stickers throughout their writing. This is especially helpful for those students who have limited vocabulary or are in the early stages of writing development. This activity is great to use for a variety of writing prompts. Likewise, the teacher can also provide ELLs with various stickers and the students can write their own creative stories based on the images (stickers) provided. Students even enjoy working with partners to complete this activity. I also find that realistic photos provide great story starters for writing as well as great ways to initiate conversations among students. I have discovered that sentence frames are effective in helping ELLs with their writing as well. My students always enjoy comparing and contrasting pictures. The various photo and online tools provided are most appreciated! I plan on utilizing many of them in my classroom with my English language learners. Thanks for the tips!

Sign in and Join the Discussion! Not a member? Register to join the discussion.