Designing a School Makerspace | Edutopia
Facebook
Edutopia on Facebook
Twitter
Edutopia on Twitter
Google+
Edutopia on Google+
Pinterest
Edutopia on Pinterest Follow Me on Pinterest
WHAT WORKS IN EDUCATION The George Lucas Educational Foundation
Subscribe to RSS

Designing a School Makerspace

Jennifer Cooper

Designer, Maker, and Gardening Teacher in Oakland, CA
Print
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Share

Makerspaces, STEAM labs and fab labs are popping up in schools across the country. Makerspaces provide hands-on, creative ways to encourage students to design, experiment, build and invent as they deeply engage in science, engineering and tinkering.

A makerspace is not solely a science lab, woodshop, computer lab or art room, but it may contain elements found in all of these familiar spaces. Therefore, it must be designed to accommodate a wide range of activities, tools and materials. Diversity and cross-pollination of activities are critical to the design, making and exploration process, and they are what set makerspaces and STEAM labs apart from single-use spaces. A possible range of activities might include:

  • Cardboard construction
  • Prototyping
  • Woodworking
  • Electronics
  • Robotics
  • Digital fabrication
  • Building bicycles and kinetic machines
  • Textiles and sewing

Designing a space to accommodate such a wide range of activities is a challenging process. Educators and administrators can help guide the process and generate the space that works best by researching, brainstorming and clearly articulating their needs, while keeping in mind inevitable changes in the future.

Some schools have chosen to incorporate makerspaces within multiple classroom spaces. This works well for many activities, particularly in elementary schools. As maker activities expand to require more tools, it makes more sense to create a dedicated makerspace that includes appropriate tools, work areas and materials. The following design approach focuses on creating dedicated makerspaces and STEAM labs.

Ask the Right Questions

Because of the constantly evolving activities that a makerspace accommodates, a flexible design is critical from the outset. Therefore, the first moves should be the right moves to result in a space that's as usable as possible. Project leads must ask critical inquiring questions to guide and inform the design process, including:

WHAT range of "subjects" will be taught in the space? What types of activities and projects could be done there?

Determine the needs and desires of all teachers in the school who will or could possibly use the space. Imagine what projects they might initiate with their students. Ideally a science, math, technology and/or art teacher would lead or participate in the brainstorming. The Makerspace Playbook is a helpful guide to envisioning the projects and activities that could happen in the makerspace. The new book Invent to Learn is a great resource for making, tinkering and engineering project ideas. The main point here is to clarify the types of activities that the space would ideally accommodate.

 

Credit: Jennifer Cooper

WHICH tools are most needed? Will digital fabrication tools such as CNC routers, laser cutters or 3D printers be included? Which materials will be used?

 

The Makerspace Playbook and Makerspace's Tools & Materials PDF document are both very useful tools for addressing these questions. They provide detailed lists of the diverse tools and materials that you might consider. Many types of equipment have special requirements, including ventilation and other elements to ensure a safe working environment. The list of tools and materials will naturally grow as specific projects and programs generate new needs, so it's good to allow for flexibility and expansion. Depending on the projects and activities, the space required for materials and project storage can be significant.

 

Credit: Jennifer Cooper

WHO are the kids that will be using the space? Will others use the space as well? Who is staffing and managing the space?

Having a space that is functional for a range of ages is key in school settings. Additionally, the space might be used for maker activities outside of class time, such as clubs (like Young Makers groups) or parent groups, as makerspaces grow into popular community hubs. At some point, the school may hire a part- or fulltime makerspace teacher. In fact, some see this as critical from the outset.

WHEN will the space be used?

Students will use the space during the school day, perhaps in a dedicated class time or with their teacher. Other opportunities may arise to maximize utility of the space after school or evenings and weekends. In this case, the design would need to accommodate access outside of school hours and for multiple users.

WHERE in the school or on the campus would be ideal? What considerations are important?

To accommodate the need for access to materials and tools, it's useful for the space to be easily accessible by cars and trucks, ideally during school day. A location close to or including outdoor work areas allows for larger or messier projects. Access to plumbing and electricity are critical. The space should be located where noise won't disturb classroom learning. Given the need for flexibility, it's good to find a place where the space could expand in the future. Finally, the makerspace would be centrally located so that it can be accessible to students, and visible so that work can be seen.

HOW will it be built? Is a new or separate structure needed, and if so what type? What is the budget? Will the design and construction team be a combination of contractor and volunteers, all-volunteer or fully contracted?

If you're lucky, there is a large space, classroom or portable just waiting for a new use, and building out the interior will be the main project. If space is at a premium, however, a new structure, portable or shipping container could potentially provide the space or some portion of it. Knowing your budget range will help determine the best way to proceed and whether you'll be able to employ contractors or need volunteers for some of the work.

Going Forward

Answering these questions will allow schools to create a "design program" for their makerspace, defining the specific needs and requirements. Because makerspaces and the activities they accommodate can vary so much, the design program is one of the most critical steps in ensuring the space will be functional and well used. The school could work with designers or architects to articulate the best ways of meeting those needs. Visits to other makerspaces or labs can be valuable and insightful during this phase, as educators envision what their space could be. A subsequent blog post will provide more information about design patterns typically found in makerspaces.

Resources:

How to Create a Maker Space

Comments (6)Sign in or register to postSubscribe to comments via RSS

Kevin Jarrett's picture
Kevin Jarrett
K-4 Technology Facilitator from Northfield, New Jersey

Hey Jennifer! Love your space, would like some information about some of the elements - particularly the work tables, which appear to possibly be your own design. Can you provide me any info? I have other questions too. Love this writeup, it's an excellent starting point for discussion and I'm relying on it heavily as I start planning for September. Thanks! -kj-

(1)
Ilya Pratt's picture
Ilya Pratt
Design+Make+Engage Director, Park Day School, Oakland CA

Hi Kevin, Jennifer asked me to step in for her for now. She did do a nice writeup, didn't she!
Regarding the workbenches, the ones pictured here are not ours, but I believe they are Sjoberg--Swedish, of course--a country with a long history of woodworking. They are available at different price points, starting around $700+shipping. Workbenches such as these are definitely biased towards woodworking. If you need a more multipurpose table, you could consider just having some masonite panels that you lay over them. If you have a limited budget and free labor, you could build tables with a couple layers of plywood and a (replaceable) masonite surface. One big factor to be aware of when choosing a table is its flex. I made some plywood & masonite tops to protect classroom tables and left a 3" lip to attach vises to. That 3" had a lot of flex and sucked up the kindergartners' already limited hammering force!
I spent a lot of time researching and considering the ideal workbenches for our space. The main factors were: suitable for various activities in addition to woodworking, price, and height adjustability. The latter factor was the most difficult to overcome. We host kindergartners (22" table height) through 8th graders (34") in our workshop, and I was determined to come up with a solution that would serve the range. Some spaces just have the smaller kids kneel on chairs, but I didn't want to resort to this. Hydraulic lift tables didn't tend to meet this range and far exceeded our budget anyway. My final solution was to design my own--a table with adjustable legs such that it has three possible heights. It's working well with only one drawback--it takes more than one person to change its height.
Happy planning!

(1)
Kevin Jarrett's picture
Kevin Jarrett
K-4 Technology Facilitator from Northfield, New Jersey

Ilya, thanks! This is great info!

We are looking at a slightly different spec, middle school only, so one height is ok. We won't be adding vises for woodworking, and just need a good portable table. We're prototyping this one:

http://www.formufit.com/pvc-maker-bench-table/

I just love the looks of the ones in the photo, but at $700 each, we'll try to save some money and get the "we made it" aesthetic in one shot. :)

Would love to see pics of your adjustable tables and how you made them, if you can share!

Finally, do you know anything about the slotted wall covering? I want that, too...

Thanks again!

-kj-

(1)
Ilya Pratt's picture
Ilya Pratt
Design+Make+Engage Director, Park Day School, Oakland CA

How's the table progressing, Kevin?
Hey I remembered you were asking about the wall material in the picture--that's slatwall, commonly found in retail clothing stores. It and its fixtures are more expensive than pegboard. A big upside to it is that it tends to pull together a space visually--resulting in a more polished looking workshop. I had some I saved from a bike shop I worked in 25(!) years ago--I just knew it would come in handy sometime....

(1)
Kevin Jarrett's picture
Kevin Jarrett
K-4 Technology Facilitator from Northfield, New Jersey

Ilya! We are waiting for the parts - they are due to arrive next week. We'll assemble one, discuss how it fits our needs, possible customizations, and then decide how to make 5 or so more.

Yes, slatwall is what I want, but pegboard is what I might get, it's my fallback. I just want the best "threshold experience" I can get - as well as storage flexibility. Slatwall is perfect, it's just so darned expensive, even in non-commercial form. We're trying to find alternatives...possibly even from out of business companies (we sadly have many of those around.)

Thanks for replying - watch for an update soon!

-kj-

(1)
Kevin Jarrett's picture
Kevin Jarrett
K-4 Technology Facilitator from Northfield, New Jersey

Ilya! We are waiting for the parts - they are due to arrive next week. We'll assemble one, discuss how it fits our needs, possible customizations, and then decide how to make 5 or so more.

Yes, slatwall is what I want, but pegboard is what I might get, it's my fallback. I just want the best "threshold experience" I can get - as well as storage flexibility. Slatwall is perfect, it's just so darned expensive, even in non-commercial form. We're trying to find alternatives...possibly even from out of business companies (we sadly have many of those around.)

Thanks for replying - watch for an update soon!

-kj-

(1)
Ilya Pratt's picture
Ilya Pratt
Design+Make+Engage Director, Park Day School, Oakland CA

How's the table progressing, Kevin?
Hey I remembered you were asking about the wall material in the picture--that's slatwall, commonly found in retail clothing stores. It and its fixtures are more expensive than pegboard. A big upside to it is that it tends to pull together a space visually--resulting in a more polished looking workshop. I had some I saved from a bike shop I worked in 25(!) years ago--I just knew it would come in handy sometime....

(1)
Kevin Jarrett's picture
Kevin Jarrett
K-4 Technology Facilitator from Northfield, New Jersey

Ilya, thanks! This is great info!

We are looking at a slightly different spec, middle school only, so one height is ok. We won't be adding vises for woodworking, and just need a good portable table. We're prototyping this one:

http://www.formufit.com/pvc-maker-bench-table/

I just love the looks of the ones in the photo, but at $700 each, we'll try to save some money and get the "we made it" aesthetic in one shot. :)

Would love to see pics of your adjustable tables and how you made them, if you can share!

Finally, do you know anything about the slotted wall covering? I want that, too...

Thanks again!

-kj-

(1)
Ilya Pratt's picture
Ilya Pratt
Design+Make+Engage Director, Park Day School, Oakland CA

Hi Kevin, Jennifer asked me to step in for her for now. She did do a nice writeup, didn't she!
Regarding the workbenches, the ones pictured here are not ours, but I believe they are Sjoberg--Swedish, of course--a country with a long history of woodworking. They are available at different price points, starting around $700+shipping. Workbenches such as these are definitely biased towards woodworking. If you need a more multipurpose table, you could consider just having some masonite panels that you lay over them. If you have a limited budget and free labor, you could build tables with a couple layers of plywood and a (replaceable) masonite surface. One big factor to be aware of when choosing a table is its flex. I made some plywood & masonite tops to protect classroom tables and left a 3" lip to attach vises to. That 3" had a lot of flex and sucked up the kindergartners' already limited hammering force!
I spent a lot of time researching and considering the ideal workbenches for our space. The main factors were: suitable for various activities in addition to woodworking, price, and height adjustability. The latter factor was the most difficult to overcome. We host kindergartners (22" table height) through 8th graders (34") in our workshop, and I was determined to come up with a solution that would serve the range. Some spaces just have the smaller kids kneel on chairs, but I didn't want to resort to this. Hydraulic lift tables didn't tend to meet this range and far exceeded our budget anyway. My final solution was to design my own--a table with adjustable legs such that it has three possible heights. It's working well with only one drawback--it takes more than one person to change its height.
Happy planning!

(1)
Kevin Jarrett's picture
Kevin Jarrett
K-4 Technology Facilitator from Northfield, New Jersey

Hey Jennifer! Love your space, would like some information about some of the elements - particularly the work tables, which appear to possibly be your own design. Can you provide me any info? I have other questions too. Love this writeup, it's an excellent starting point for discussion and I'm relying on it heavily as I start planning for September. Thanks! -kj-

(1)

blog Supporting Maker Education District-Wide

Last comment 1 week 1 hour ago in Maker Education

article Arts Integration: Resource Roundup

Last comment 1 week 2 hours ago in Arts Integration

blog School Makerspaces: Building the Buzz

Last comment 1 week 6 hours ago in Maker Education

blog Starting a School Makerspace from Scratch

Last comment 1 week 1 day ago in Maker Education

blog Fostering Creativity With Makerspaces

Last comment 1 week 5 days ago in Maker Education

Sign in to comment. Not a member? Register.