Comments (26)

Comment RSS
Education Specialist

Sadly in a day and age of

Was this helpful?
0

Sadly in a day and age of CCSS & Race to the Top I have routinely witnessed kids who are quickly placed into special ed and then alternative ed so that hem standardized test scores won't effect their "home school", and by placing them into alt ed the cost is minimized. I wish your reality were the nation's Ben.

Administrator, author and educator

Thanks! Point well taken. BJ

Was this helpful?
0

Thanks! Point well taken.
BJ

Community Manager at Edutopia

I'm going to step in and note

Was this helpful?
0

I'm going to step in and note that this discussion is drifting towards the personal. We appreciate a vigorous discussion, but please let's keep things respectful.

Administrator, author and educator

ZEP: You rant an rave about

Was this helpful?
0

ZEP:

You rant an rave about others being subjective and biased and then you eloquently display your own biases. For example, no administrator could force a student to be in the special ed. program, it is a committee decision including the parents and teachers. Students need to be tested, and that costs the district money, teachers need to be surveyed and that takes away time, and special ed teachers are already spread thin with large case loads. You speak of administrators like some all powerful evil dictators. No administrator in his right mind would even think of that because of the morass of paperwork, testing, meetings and allocation of resources special education requires. And by the way, there is no life altering transformation that occurs when a teacher becomes an administrator. All administrators are still teachers, with other duties. Lashing out at the "establishment" and the white middle class only further establishes your agenda and racial biases. Give it a rest! Mr. Vilson and Edutopia are putting forth solutions, where are yours?

[quote]This is a bit of a repeat, but on a daily basis I work with students K-12 who supposedly are "special ed", erstwhile there is nothing wrong with 99% of these kids other than they upset an administrator due to their behavioral choices which challenged the status quo. quote]

Ben Johnson
San Antonio, Texas

Education Specialist

Actually, every citation in

Was this helpful?
0

Actually, every citation in The War On Kids is validated peer reviewed research. You or anyone else on this ;blog is encouraged to pull up the citations as I did and check them one by one which obviously any researcher worth their salt would do. The impact of policy (circa 1950's GI Bill) i.e. refusing low % loans for buying homes, to anyone considered non-white, is irrefutable, perhaps reality such as this is why you choose to ignore well respected authors such as Delpit? The impact of this one policy is substantial as white families were able to use their govt subsidized home as collateral for their children's college tuition and expand the wealth gap, perhaps you've noticed that wealth inequality has skyrocketed over the past 30 years? Racist policies &/or implementation of policies has had a snowball effect which creates major challenges for urban youth today. Failure to acknowledge this reality handicaps efforts to truly facilitate our children's growth.

Life Skills Support Teacher

As far as this website goes,

Was this helpful?
0

As far as this website goes, I think it would benefit its credibility considerably by requiring that posters register under their real names and not anonymous monikers.

Life Skills Support Teacher

As far as capitalist

Was this helpful?
+1

As far as capitalist "leaching" (sic), the actual leeches are the career politicians who constantly throw taxpayer dollars at unsolvable problems in society in order to stay in power. Count me out of your hackneyed haves vs. have-not argument. I don't look at my at-risk students and see victims like you likely do. I prefer to focus on tangible issues like helping qualified students access the special education services they are entitled to by law. Besides, you have NO scientific basis for your argument against kids being diagnosed with emotional disturbance by qualified personnel. 99%? Amazing how some people can watch a film so biased and absent of credible peer reviewed research and treat the half-baked conclusions like gospel. The gullibility of some people just amazes me sometimes.

Education Specialist

This is a bit of a repeat,

Was this helpful?
0

This is a bit of a repeat, but on a daily basis I work with students K-12 who supposedly are "special ed", erstwhile there is nothing wrong with 99% of these kids other than they upset an administrator due to their behavioral choices which challenged the status quo. Often these students go on to be the "thinkers" or those who act on their consciousness. You obviously rely heavily on diagnoses which are all highly subjective; the statistics in the film are all documented, sorry if you refuse to believe what's really happening to our urban students of color in particular, which brings us full circle, back to Delpit who understands that you can't fix the schools without stopping the capitalist leaching which has occurred in our urban centers for at least the last 50 years, but particularly the last 30, all under the guise of supply-side unregulated economics.

Life Skills Support Teacher

I see people with faith in

Was this helpful?
0

I see people with faith in higher powers as more happy and optimistic people. I see secularists as often bitter. unsatisfied, cynical, and given to moral ambiguity. I would prefer a teacher to be of the former mindset and I'm sure most parents in America would, too. Why would anyone want their child to be around the latter type?

Life Skills Support Teacher

zep: that video has to be the

Was this helpful?
0

zep: that video has to be the biggest load of tripe this side of a Michael Moore or Al Gore propaganda hit piece. Nevertheless, to partially educate you on the topic correctly, pediatricians, psychologists, as well as highly qualified special ed teachers, issue thorough examinations to determine if a child exhibits the level of behaviors to warrant a diagnosis of emotional disturbance. It's part of special education law. I would suggest you read up on it.

see more see less